How To Find The Right Accountant For Your Small Business

Share On Facebook

This is a guest post by Tyler Wells who is a certified public accountant. For all of you who don’t know Tyler, he’s an unrepentant nerd for numbers with a passion for accounting, finance, and small business.

Tyler’s love for entrepreneurialism took root while working on his family’s exotic animal farm and blossomed while advising entrepreneurs as a Peace Corps volunteer in Guatemala.

Choosing an accountant is a bit like choosing a life partner, it can be too easy to rush into a relationship, make a choice for all the wrong reasons, and once you’ve finally realized that you made a mistake, find out changing can be a real headache, not to mention expensive.

Well, it’s not totally like a romantic relationship because at least accountants don’t give you in-laws! However, it may be the most important professional relationship you have and this guide should help you get it right.

The following are essential factors to consider when choosing your accountant:


Are you only looking for your accountant to prepare your 1040 (personal tax return in the U.S.) and to report your side business activity on your Schedule C?

Or perhaps you run several businesses that are all distinct entities and require their own returns and operate across state lines? Furthermore, get this, accountants do much more than just prepare tax returns!

Audits, reviews and compilations, tax planning, business valuation, payroll, and just plain providing you the information that you need to manage and grow your business are some of the many services accountants can provide.


In the United States any schmo can prepare your tax return but only lawyers, Certified Public Accountants, and Enrolled Agents can legally sign your return and represent you before the IRS should the need arise.

In other English speaking countries the appropriate designation is a chartered accountant. By signing your return, your accountant is actually taking some limited responsibility for your return; that is, they aren’t taking responsibility for the information that you gave them but they are assuming some responsibility for the proper treatment of that information.


Usually, the more complex your return is, the more likely it is that you will be charged by the hour. This can make it extremely difficult to price-shop accounting services but most will give you a ballpark figure and, if you’re an obnoxious pain in the ass, count on paying much more than that.


Is your accountant familiar with and able to work with your accounting system? Are you the type that expects your accountant to work with you online, possibly giving them access to your Quickbooks accounts, or are you more like that person that sends in the shoebox of receipts and a check register and asks them to work their magic?

Does you accountant have the ability to work with the software that you use? If not, can you download everything into Excel? Expectations for technological and systems compatibility need to be addressed before engaging an accountant.


You don’t have to want to take your accountant on your honeymoon with you, but you ought to at least feel comfortable calling them up and asking them about the tax implications of any major purchases or big business deals you plan on making (before you make them, please!).

Accountants have the reputation of being stodgy, conservative, and not the best communicators in the world. However, after years of working in the industry and meeting tons of accountants through work, school, and professional associations I can honestly say that, yeah man, it’s mostly true.


More and more people are wired in and used to doing business by phone and Internet, so much so that geography is no longer the factor that it once was.

However, if you’re a last minute type of girl and you know that you will need to drive to your accountant’s office on the 15th of April to sign some documents then it’s probably best that your accountant isn’t located in, say, Bangalore or Manila.

My Two Cents

Since you are reading My Wife Quit Her Job and since it is an awesome resource for Internet entrepreneurship I am going to assume that you own your own business or are a freelancer.

If all you think you’ll ever need is tax preparation, an Enrolled Agent or even, if your return is simple enough, H&R Block are perfectly adequate.

However, for those of you with larger aspirations and who want to use their accounting records for tax and business planning as well as for filing your tax return, my advice is to look for an accountant at a small or mid-sized firm that specializes in working with business owners.

Wait until summer and then call up some accountants who fit the bill or who have been referred to you and talk to them. In my opinion, these are some of the questions your accountant should ask:

  • What your business is and how it makes you money,
  • To see your prior year’s tax returns, including those of your business if you file a separate return for it, and to discuss some of the items on it and ask you about some of the tax strategies used,
  • What level of service you are looking for,
  • What your immediate plans for your business are.

Look for an accountant that is interested in your business and seems familiar with what you do. Also, look for an accountant that informs you about the full range of services that they could offer you, even if you’re only in the market for a tax preparer right now.

No, I’m not just saying this to drum up business for my colleagues. Look, you’re a busy person and even if you know how to do everything you can’t possibly do it all.

So a little interest from your accountant and information on the services they offer might end up saving you time and making you money.

By the same token, you should be asking them:

  • How they bill for their services,
  • Whether they have any expertise in your industry,
  • Who will actually prepare your tax return. It is not a joke that some of the big firms will farm your return out to India. This is not necessarily a bad thing because even in my smaller firm at least two people look at every return and it is the person who signs it that you are most concerned with. Still, it is worth knowing who you should call when you have questions.
  • What their golf handicap is. Alright, I know that there are at least 5 accountants who don’t golf (I’m one) but you at least want to know if they are someone that you feel comfortable talking to. Your accountant can be a great reference and also a great source of referrals if you take the time to get to know them and they take the time to understand your business and its needs.


As you establish your relationship with your accountant you should begin to get a feel for her integrity. If you value your integrity and want to get your return right then don’t just make sure your accountant complies with your wishes, make sure that uncompromising integrity is a basis of their practice.

There are few things quite so nasty and having an IRS agent combing through your business records because they have uncovered other shady dealings by your accountant with different clients.

Sure, if you’re on the up and up everything will come out fine in the end but what an incredible waste of time and effort and immense source of stress.

On the other hand, if your accountant has done her job and you have faith in them then there’s no reason to lose any sleep over it. Two names go on the return, make sure that both of them are on the same page.

Well, there’s my two cents, have you anything to add? Do you have a horror story of an accountant gone bad or even a story about how your accountant helped your business become more profitable? Let us know!

Editor’s Note: This past year, my wife and I decided to perform an experiment with respect to filing our taxes. Instead of just using Turbo Tax like we normally do, we had an accountant file our taxes for us and compared the accountant’s results with Turbo Tax.

In case you missed it, I reported my results in my article entitled the outcome of hiring an accountant to do our taxes vs Turbo Tax. Unfortunately, the accountant didn’t do so well.

But in the back of mind, I couldn’t help but think that it was partially my fault for not choosing the right accountant. I wish Tyler had written this article earlier…

Ready To Get Serious About Starting An Online Business?

If you are really considering starting your own online business, then you have to check out my free mini course on How To Create A Niche Online Store In 5 Easy Steps.

In this 6 day mini course, I reveal the steps that my wife and I took to earn 100 thousand dollars in the span of just a year. Best of all, it's absolutely free!

Share On Facebook
Note: This post above may contain affiliate links, which means that I may receive a commission if you make a purchase when clicking a link. Please consult our privacy policy for more information.

Similar Posts

Have you read these?

26 thoughts on “How To Find The Right Accountant For Your Small Business”

  1. Kai says:

    I love my accountant. Anyone can file your taxes for you but as with any consultant, it’s the relationship that counts. The advice I get from my CPA is priceless

  2. I didn’t realize how much an accountant could do for you. I have 2 businesses and am thinking about phasing out of one and starting another. Now I’m thinking I should talk with my accountant 1st. THANKS!

  3. Linda says:

    We’ve had the same accountant for over 20 years and LOVE him because he is of the highest integrity and he insists that we are also.

  4. Anita says:

    I run all my major business decisions by my accountant first. He’s a been an invaluable resource to me and to my small business.

  5. I think personality might sound funny here but it’s true that you can tell what kind of person they are behind the scenes from it. You don’t want to have to communicate with someone who is in charge of your money and is an angry person. Imagine what they’re holding back!

  6. Great advice. I’ve been doing my own accounting but it’s time that I hire an accountant. Thanks for these tips

  7. Alex Quinn says:

    It is important for your business to find good NY cpa firms to take care of your finances, especially in these bad economic times. You should look for NY CPA firms that you can trust to take care of your records. The right CPA can be an invaluable resource for you. They can do things such as manage your finances and revenue, stand up for you before the IRS, and they can give you very sound financial advise that will help you to grow, even with regards to your personal finances.

  8. Great advice Steve, I couldn’t agree more. Compatibility, personality, experience, and integrity were a few of the qualities I looked for when hiring an accountant for my business. I chose Tanner LLC, one of the leading accounting firms in Utah and I have been continuously pleased with my experience. The associates at Tanner LLC have helped me to be the most efficient and profitable business owner I can be.

  9. “most will give you a ballpark figure and, if you’re an obnoxious pain in the ass, count on paying much more than that”

    Brilliant advice and very true!

    I have to agree with what’s being said here – Personality is a very important factor when making this decision. I get on very well with my CPA and it definitely makes a difference!

    Jon @ Choose your Accountant

  10. This is a great piece and I think that a few of the points, most particularly the compatibility and personality can be applied no matter where you are in the world. A lot of people simply go for the first and often cheapest accountant they find but with a little time and effort there is no reason why they cannot find someone that really can protect their business.

  11. Very useful information. One of the best ways to find the right account for your business it through referral or recommendations from your colleagues. If you run a small business, it is typically a good idea going to your professional associations just like the local Chamber of commerce, if you’re a member and get referrals there. You can get good, reliable accountants quickly.

  12. Businesses don’t only need accountants during tax season. To ensure business growth, hire accountants who can deliver more value to your business with his sound business advice and solutions.

  13. Great information and advice, thanks for sharing. Choosing an accountant with Experience/credentials is a sensible idea, also it is important to make sure you choose and accountant that you can trust.

  14. These are really good tips on what to look for when hiring a CPA firm. It makes sense that if a tax return for a company is large that it would cost more to get it done. I know I would rather hire someone that can get the job done right, so no problems will happen.

  15. I have a friend that is trying to start up his own business, and money has been a struggle. I had no idea that the more complex the return, the more likely they will charge by the hour. I think it’s great that there are people that work with money for a living and know exactly what to do.

  16. Some great suggestions. Finding an accountant that is compatible with your personality and business objectives is key. And to find someone that you can get along with and have good communications with is a point that is often overlooked. But I like what you said “You don’t have to want to take your accountant on your honeymoon with you, but you ought to at least feel comfortable calling them”
    Thanks for the post very helpful

  17. I love that you include personality in the decision. If you don’t feel comfortable talking to your accountant, then you won’t be able to communicate properly. Communication is vital, especially when dealing with money.

  18. I liked when you said that when choosing an accountant you need to understand the level of serve you need. It makes sense that doing this can help you pay for what you need. It is important to remember to shop around and find someone who has what it takes to help you.

  19. I didn’t know that Certified Public Accountants are able to sign tax returns and even represent you for the IRS. That sounds like a big help for a small business owner. Filing my personal taxes is confusing enough, so I can only imagine how much more complicated filing for a business would be. Thanks for the helpful information about choosing the right accountant.

  20. I did not know that in the United Stated only lawyers, Certified Public Accountants, and Enrolled Agents can legally sign your return and represent you. Working with the proper people could be important to make sure everything goes smoothly. Looking into different CPA firms and getting things done as quickly as possible would probably be important to avoid any problems.

  21. I just wanted to thank you for going over some things to consider when trying to find an accountant for a small business. I appreciate that you mentioned to learn about what kinds of skills and services an accountant can offer, like maybe helping with payroll and making plans. Sounds like this could be incredibly beneficial if you want to make sure that you can focus on the main focus of your business. Plus, you would be handing that accounting work of to another professional so that it can be done right.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *