458: The Ugly Truth About Selling On Amazon And The Hidden Fees With Vladi Gordon

Podcast: Download (Duration: 52:06 — 59.9MB)

Amazon has more than 100 different small fees that quietly erode your profit, and the biggest profit killer of all is returns, because a single return on a $20 product can wipe out the profit from three sales after you account for the refund administration fee (~5-6% of price), the lost FBA fulfillment fee, return-shipping charges (up to another full FBA fee), and the cost of goods on any item that comes back damaged. That is the core of my conversation with Vladi Gordon, founder of Sellerboard, on the My Wife Quit Her Job podcast.

Vladi is a former Amazon seller (he was one of the first FBA sellers of Google Cardboard VR headsets in Germany around 2014) turned software founder. His profit-and-loss tool for Amazon sellers was built out of his own frustration trying to figure out whether he was actually profitable, and it now costs $15 a month, which makes it one of the cheapest tools of its kind on the market.

Below is the full breakdown of every hidden Amazon FBA fee category we covered, the true math on Amazon returns, why PPC break-even is harder than most sellers think, and answers to the questions I get most often about tracking Amazon profitability.

Get My Free Mini Course On How To Start A Successful Ecommerce Store

If you are interested in starting an ecommerce business, I put together a comprehensive package of resources that will help you launch your own online store from complete scratch. Be sure to grab it before you leave!

Click Here To Download

Key takeaways

• Amazon’s revenue dashboard never subtracts refunds from your revenue number, so most sellers overestimate their profit for weeks or months.
• Returns are the single most underestimated profit killer. A $20 item returned can cancel the profit from three sales at typical margins.
• You lose the FBA fulfillment fee on a return, and Amazon sometimes charges a second FBA-sized fee for return shipping (fashion in particular).
• Amazon charges a refund administration fee of roughly 5-6% of item price (essentially a referral fee on the referral fee) on refunds in many categories.
• Amazon has more than 100 different fee line items scattered across their reports (storage, inbound transportation, lightning-deal fees, coupon redemption, disposal, labeling, polybagging, and more).
• Return rates vary wildly by category, from ~2% on batteries up to ~50% in fashion. Reducing return rate by even 1% can lift profit by ~20%.
• Amazon PPC uses a 14-day attribution window that credits sales of any product from the seller after a click, which makes true break-even calculations harder.
• The 80/20 rule applies to Amazon portfolios: roughly 20% of your SKUs generate about 80% of your profit, and you need product-level P&L to see which is which.

Who Vladi Gordon is and why he built Sellerboard

Vladi Gordon is a former software engineer at IBM who became an Amazon FBA seller in Germany around 2014, then built Sellerboard because no existing tool showed him whether he was actually profitable. He started with Google Cardboard VR headsets (the fold-up cardboard viewer Google open-sourced right when Facebook acquired Oculus), which took off as a first-mover FBA product before competition compressed margins.

At his peak he had roughly 20 SKUs (ties, phone tripods, drink coasters, VR headsets) sourced arbitrage-style from AliExpress and Alibaba. That portfolio taught him that Amazon selling is a real business, not a diamond mine, and that most SKUs do not repeat the outsize wins of the first one.

When margins tightened on his main product, he started looking for a profit-tracking tool, could not find one he liked at a price he was willing to pay, and partnered with a friend to build Sellerboard. He eventually sold his Amazon business to focus on the software.

Why Amazon’s revenue dashboard is lying to you

Amazon’s dashboard adds revenue when a sale happens but never subtracts revenue when the item is refunded, so the top-line number you see in Seller Central is systematically higher than what you actually keep. Refunds show up separately if you go looking, but the top-line “units sold” and “revenue” columns keep the original sale.

The practical result: most sellers estimate profit by taking units sold in Seller Central and multiplying by a rough per-unit profit they calculated on a napkin during product research. That estimate ignores refunds entirely and consistently overstates profit.

Every guru screenshot you see on YouTube or Instagram showing seven or eight figures in Amazon revenue is using this same inflated top-line number. Revenue is a vanity metric. Profit is what matters.

Why returns are the single biggest hidden Amazon profit killer

Returns are the largest hidden Amazon FBA cost because a single refund triggers multiple simultaneous losses that compound: you refund the customer’s full purchase price, you lose the FBA fulfillment fee you already paid, you often pay another FBA-sized fee for return shipping, and you may lose the entire cost of goods if the item comes back damaged. The one thing you do get back is the referral fee (Amazon’s ~15% commission), which softens the loss but does not eliminate it.

The math is brutal at typical margins. If your profit per unit is $6 and you refund a $20 sale, that single return effectively cancels three previous sales’ worth of profit.

Bookkeeping-wise, the cleanest way to handle returns is to book the loss on the day the return happens rather than retroactively editing the original sale month. Sellerboard uses this method by default, which is why refund events show up as negative profit hits in real time.

The full list of Amazon return fees you actually pay

Here is every line item that hits you when a customer returns an item.

• Refund administration fee (~5-6% of item price). A “referral fee on the referral fee” that Amazon charges to process the refund. Does not apply to every category, but common. Non-refundable.
• Lost FBA fulfillment fee. You paid Amazon to ship the item to the customer. You do not get that back.
• Return-shipping fee (up to another full FBA fee). In many categories (fashion especially), Amazon charges you a second FBA-sized fee to ship the item from the customer back to the warehouse. Total FBA-related loss on a return can therefore run 15-30% of item price.
• Cost of goods (if damaged). Amazon inspects returned items. If they mark it damaged, you lose the entire cost of goods. If they mark it sellable, that cost is added back to inventory.
• Ongoing storage fees on damaged items. Damaged returns sit in the warehouse racking up storage fees until you dispose of them or ship them back to yourself.
• Disposal or inbound shipping fees. Removing damaged inventory costs money either way. Shipping back to your own warehouse is cheaper (~inbound rates) than Amazon disposal in some cases.

The one line item you get back: the referral fee (Amazon’s ~15% commission) is refunded when the sale is refunded. In Europe, VAT also comes back.

Return rate benchmarks by category

Return rates vary wildly by product category, from ~2% on cheap batteries up to ~50% on fashion, so your benchmark should be category-specific rather than a blanket average. Rough working numbers:

• Batteries and cheap consumables: under 2%
• Home and kitchen: single digits
• Overall Amazon average: ~10%
• Electronics: 15-20%
• Apparel and fashion: up to ~50%

Reducing your return rate by even 1 percentage point can lift net profit by ~20%, because you avoid all the compounding fees above, not just the refunded revenue. Small improvements in return rate are one of the highest-ROI things you can work on as an Amazon seller.

Easy ways to reduce your Amazon return rate

The easiest way to cut Amazon returns is to fix the reason customers are actually returning your product, and Amazon tells you the reason in a report most sellers ignore. Go to Reports > FBA > Customer Concessions and look at the “return reason” column plus any free-text comments customers left.

Common fixable reasons and their fixes:

• “Bigger/smaller than I thought.” Add photos with a size reference (a coin, a hand, a known object) so buyers can visually gauge dimensions before purchasing.
• “Color doesn’t match the picture.” Retake or color-correct product photos. Add multiple angles in realistic lighting. Buyers’ screen and lighting conditions vary a lot.
• “Not as described.” Tighten your bullet points and title. Remove any language that oversells the product.

Warning: aggressively rewriting listings to reduce returns can also cause conversion rate to drop or trigger Amazon flags. Change one thing at a time, watch the return rate over 30 days, and iterate.

Beyond returns: the other hidden Amazon fees

Beyond returns, Amazon charges more than 100 distinct fees scattered across their reports, and most sellers only account for the two or three obvious ones. The ones sellers most commonly miss:

• Inbound transportation. Roughly $3+ per box to ship inventory to an Amazon warehouse. Small per box, meaningful at volume.
• Monthly Professional Seller subscription. $39.99/month baseline. Small but real.
• Long-term and monthly storage fees. Not uniform per unit; hard to attribute to specific SKUs without software.
• Lightning Deals fee. Per-deal fee on top of the discount.
• Coupon redemption fee. Per-coupon fee on top of the discount.
• Removal and disposal fees. For pulling inventory out of FBA or destroying it.
• Labeling, polybagging, bubble-wrap, prep fees. If Amazon prepares your inventory rather than you.
• FBA inbound defect fee. If your inbound shipment arrives damaged or improperly labeled.
• Sales-tax collection fee. Where applicable.

Vladi’s rule of thumb: build in at least a 10% revenue buffer to your expected profit margin to cover the fees you are not tracking line by line. If your product does not have enough gross margin to absorb that buffer, the SKU is not a viable long-term product.

The Amazon warehouse “lost then found” fee trap

There is a specific holiday-season fee pattern most sellers do not know about: Amazon tends to lose inventory during Q4 when volumes are highest, reimburses you for the lost units, then “miraculously finds” them in January and claws the reimbursement back, without compensating you for the sales you missed during the peak. That is a real cost that never shows up as a fee line item.

Amazon reimburses you for the inventory itself, but they do not reimburse you for opportunity cost, including lost sales during your best selling weeks or dropped keyword rank because your listing went out of stock. That opportunity cost can be many times larger than the reimbursement.

Sellerboard shows reimbursements the day they hit your account, so you can spot the pattern and plan inventory buffers for next year’s Q4.

Why Amazon PPC break-even is harder to calculate than you think

Amazon PPC break-even is deceptively hard because Amazon’s ad reporting attributes any sale of any product from your account within a 14-day window after a click, not just the specific product being advertised. That means the “PPC revenue” number you see in the advertising console overstates the actual return on that specific campaign.

Most sellers should think about PPC in one of three modes:

• Product launch mode: profitability does not matter. Buy sales to trigger organic ranking.
• Support mode: break-even PPC to keep organic rank healthy. Do not lose money, but do not require profit either.
• Profit mode: require PPC to be genuinely profitable. Getting harder every year as competition rises.

For break-even or profit mode, use your profit margin on the advertised product as your target ACoS (advertising cost of sales) rule of thumb. From there, work backward through conversion rate to your break-even bid.

Example: at a $2 target profit per unit and a 10% click-to-sale conversion rate, your break-even bid is $0.20 per click. Sellerboard tries to compute this more precisely per keyword by pulling in additional API data that the advertising console does not display.

Why the 80/20 rule matters for your Amazon SKU portfolio

Roughly 20% of your Amazon SKUs will generate about 80% of your true profit, so you need product-level P&L to know which SKUs are actually paying the bills and which are quietly losing money in aggregate. Total top-line profit hides losing SKUs when they are averaged in with the winners.

Without product-level tracking, sellers keep restocking losing SKUs because “overall profit is positive.” With it, you can spot the losers, cut them, and shift working capital into the winners.

This is not unique to Amazon. It is true of most product businesses, but Amazon’s fragmented fee structure makes it especially hard to see without software.

Frequently asked questions

What are the hidden fees when selling on Amazon FBA?

Amazon FBA has more than 100 distinct fee line items beyond the two obvious ones (~15% referral fee and per-unit FBA fulfillment fee). The biggest hidden costs are refund administration fees, return shipping, lost FBA fees on returned units, storage fees on damaged inventory, and dozens of smaller line items like Lightning Deals fees, coupon redemption fees, inbound transportation, and prep charges.

How much does the average Amazon return actually cost?

A single return can cost the seller 30-70% of the item’s sale price after adding up the refund administration fee (~5-6%), the lost FBA fulfillment fee (10-15% of price), return shipping (up to another 15%), and the cost of goods if the item comes back damaged. At typical margins, one return can cancel the profit from three previous sales.

What is the average Amazon return rate?

Overall Amazon return rates average about 10% across categories, but individual categories vary massively: batteries and cheap consumables under 2%, home and kitchen in the single digits, electronics 15-20%, and apparel or fashion up to ~50%.

Does Amazon subtract refunds from your revenue number?

No. Amazon’s Seller Central dashboard adds revenue when a sale occurs but does not subtract it when the item is refunded, so your top-line revenue number is systematically higher than what you actually keep. You have to pull refund data from separate reports to see true net revenue.

What is the best software to track Amazon profit and loss?

Sellerboard is one of the least expensive Amazon P&L tools on the market at $15/month and covers per-unit profit tracking, cash flow, and inventory. Alternatives include Helium 10 (bundled inside their broader suite) and ManageByStats. Any dedicated P&L tool is better than trying to reconcile Amazon’s raw reports by hand.

How does Amazon PPC attribution work?

Amazon PPC uses a 14-day attribution window and credits any sale of any product from the seller after a click, not just the specific product being advertised. That means the reported PPC revenue overstates the actual return on the specific campaign, which makes break-even and profit calculations harder to do accurately without third-party tooling.

What is a good Amazon FBA profit margin?

A healthy Amazon FBA net profit margin after all hidden fees, returns, and PPC is typically 15-25% of revenue. Anything below 10% leaves you dangerously exposed to fee increases, return-rate spikes, or PPC cost inflation. If your product cannot support a 10%+ buffer after realistic returns and fees, the SKU is not a viable long-term business.

Ready To Get Serious About Starting An Online Business?

If you are really considering starting your own online business, then you have to check out my free mini course on How To Create A Niche Online Store In 5 Easy Steps.

In this 6 day mini course, I reveal the steps that my wife and I took to earn 100 thousand dollars in the span of just a year. Best of all, it's absolutely free!