Podcast: Download (Duration: 42:19 — 48.7MB)
Amazon’s new ad types include review ads that ask your buyers for a review, branded conversations ads inside the Alexa for Shopping AI assistant, and an automated campaign that works like Google Performance Max. Amazon also announced a dashboard for managing all your sales channels in one place.
Every one of these gives sellers another way to pay Amazon. By my rough numbers, Amazon’s ad business grew close to 20% while ecommerce grew around 15%, which means sellers are paying more for the same sales.
In this episode, my co-host Toni Herrbach and I break down each new ad type, the one we both think is ingenious and irritating at the same time, and the multichannel tool we think you should avoid.
Get My Free Mini Course On How To Start A Successful Ecommerce Store
If you are interested in starting an ecommerce business, I put together a comprehensive package of resources that will help you launch your own online store from complete scratch. Be sure to grab it before you leave!
Table of Contents
Key takeaways
- Review ads are the big one. You bid for ads that ask your past buyers for a review, and Amazon says they will triple the review rate.
- Review ads only apply to products with fewer than 1,000 reviews, which keeps them focused on product launches.
- Branded conversations put sponsored Q&A into Alexa for Shopping. The earlier sponsored prompts version produced about a 6% conversion lift.
- Amazon’s automated campaign is a black box. In my experience with Google Performance Max, you lose the ability to cut wasted spend.
- The multichannel dashboard hands Amazon your sales data from Shopify, Walmart, TikTok, and every other channel you connect.
- Every new cost favors established sellers, and the number of sellers doing over $100 million on Amazon has roughly tripled.
What new ad types did Amazon announce?
Amazon announced three new ad types at its two back-to-back events: review ads, branded conversations ads, and an automated campaign that decides where your ads run. Here is how each one works and what Toni and I think of it.
| New Amazon offering | How it works | Our take |
|---|---|---|
| Review ads | You bid to show review requests to people who bought your product | Ingenious for Amazon, another ongoing cost for sellers |
| Branded conversations | Sponsored questions under your listing open a conversation in Alexa for Shopping | Cleverly done, with unproven sales impact |
| Automated campaign | You supply creative and keywords, and Amazon decides where ads appear | A black box that is hard to control |
| Multichannel dashboard | Manage Shopify, Walmart, and other channels in one place | Gives Amazon your data from every channel |
None of these were live yet when we recorded, so our opinions are based on what Amazon announced.
Amazon branded conversations ads in Alexa for Shopping
Branded conversations ads let sellers pay to place sponsored questions under a product listing that open a conversation in Alexa for Shopping, Amazon’s AI shopping agent. A cleaning product listing might show “Why choose this home cleaning product?” with a clear sponsored label.
Another example was a food processor with the question “How does this perform with dense bread dough?” Clicking it opens Alexa for Shopping, and the answer draws on the information the seller is paying to promote.
The timing caught our attention. Amazon announced these ads right after it blocked outside AI shopping agents like Meta’s Muse, Perplexity, and Google from its site.
I think the design is clever. A Harris poll found that about 79% of people would stop trusting an AI’s answers if they saw ads in them, so Amazon keeps the ad under the product and out of the AI’s answer.
Toni likes the format for shoppers, because helpful Q&A sells products. Her family makes bread, and she would never buy a mixer that could not handle bread dough.
How sponsored prompts led to branded conversations
Branded conversations are an evolution of sponsored prompts, which Amazon launched for free in 2025. Sellers saw a modest conversion lift of about 6%, and Amazon started charging for sponsored prompts in March.
When I searched Amazon to find the old sponsored prompts, I could not get any to show up. I also struggled to find the Alexa for Shopping button, and Amazon removed an always-open version from the left panel after an experiment about a year ago.
Will Amazon’s AI shopping ads increase sales?
Amazon’s AI shopping ads may not increase sales much, because most shoppers already know what they want when they arrive. Toni needed cheap headphones for the podcast and airplanes, searched for Skullcandy because she had bought them before, and picked a pair by price.
I buy stainless steel forks about every six months, and I just grab the cheapest 18/10 set with more than a couple of reviews. Neither of us does product research on Amazon or has ever opened Alexa to shop.
Amazon says shoppers who open Alexa for Shopping convert about 60% higher, and that makes sense because they already have high intent. Amazon’s stats talk about more conversations and higher conversion rates, and none of them mention an increase in sales.
After years in marketing, Toni has learned that a company that cannot show a sales increase usually does not have an impressive one. That is when the metrics shift to brand awareness and engagement.
Amazon review ads: paying for reviews from verified buyers
Amazon review ads work like any other Amazon ad, except you bid for a slot that shows review requests to people who have already bought your product. Amazon says the ads will increase the review rate by three times.
Getting reviews has been tough since Amazon banned incentivized reviews. The automatic Request a Review button converts okay, and a product insert asking for a review converts horribly, probably 1% or less.
Reviews matter enormously. According to the stats Toni found, a product with 1 to 10 reviews gets a conversion lift of more than 50%, the lift roughly doubles past 10 reviews, and it roughly triples past 100.
Only products with fewer than 1,000 reviews qualify, and Amazon says the ads turn off automatically at 1,000. Toni likes that, because it focuses review ads on product launches and stops listings with 30,000 reviews from dominating even further.
Review ads could also help with fake reviews. If paying Amazon for a review costs less than the gray hat and black hat options, fewer sellers will have a reason to cheat.
Why Amazon review ads favor established sellers
Amazon review ads favor established sellers because they are an ongoing auction that bigger brands can afford to leave on forever. Amazon’s earlier review programs were one-time payments.
- Amazon Vine was a one-time payment for reviews.
- The Early Reviewer Program cost about $60 back in the day for your first five reviews.
- Review ads are a continuous bid against other sellers, which drives the price up.
You already pay to make your product visible in search. After all that work to get a conversion, you now pay again to get the review.
I think Amazon is turning into a K-shaped economy, where established sellers thrive and new sellers drown in sponsored products ads, brand ads, review ads, and new fees. Toni points out that sellers with cash can now buy their way into a market on both PPC and social proof.
Shoppers will never know. They get a quick message asking for a review and have no idea a seller paid for it.
How much to spend on Amazon review ads on a budget
If you are on a budget, I would pay for Amazon review ads until your product reaches about 100 reviews. On an extreme budget, pay until you hit 10, which is where the biggest conversion jump happens.
Nobody knows the pricing yet because it is an auction. The ads only reach people who bought from you, so there may not be much bidding overlap between sellers.
Amazon’s automated ad campaign works like Google Performance Max
Amazon’s new automated ad campaign works like Google Performance Max: you hand over creative and keywords, and Amazon decides where to show your ads. You pay into a black box, which is pretty ingenious for Amazon.
My Google experience makes me wary. When Google launched Performance Max, it reduced the visibility of its other ad types to push everyone into it, and that is the only reason I started using it.
I monitor my Performance Max campaigns more closely than anything else because I have no control over them, and I have an AI agent report on their performance. Leading up to Google’s earnings, I started wasting a lot more money.
The biggest waste for me is Google Discover, which is like TikTok for blog posts. If I had my way, I would turn off Discover, email ads, and probably the display network altogether.
Google does let me exclude specific websites from display ads, and display converts for me on certain sites. The problem is that AI creates millions of spammy websites, and blocking them is a game of whack-a-mole.
Toni agrees that automated campaigns make sense in theory. Meta works similarly, though Meta still lets you turn placements off, and with a true black box you cannot shut down a problem and move the spend elsewhere.
Amazon’s multichannel dashboard: why sellers should think twice
Amazon’s multichannel dashboard lets you manage Shopify, Walmart, and your other sales channels in one place, and Toni and I think sellers should avoid it. Connecting your other channels hands Amazon all of your sales data.
We both rolled our eyes at this one. A podcast we respect touted it as the next big thing, since nobody big has built a good multichannel dashboard, and selling across channels really is hard.
Amazon competes against its own sellers. It has required sellers to disclose their manufacturer to keep selling, and Toni and I have friends who were knocked off by Amazon.
- Carol Raines sold emu oil until Amazon made its own version about 30% cheaper.
- Our friend Mike sold ice wraps, and Amazon copied his packaging, the look and feel of his product, and similar graphics with a different brand name, which really hurt his business.
Toni is dealing with this right now. She is putting some of a client’s products on Amazon and keeping others off so they do not get knocked off, and a connected dashboard would show Amazon the numbers from TikTok, Shopify, and Faire anyway.
Why Amazon’s changes squeeze small sellers
Amazon’s changes squeeze small sellers because each new paid tool is easier for big brands to absorb. I believe the number of sellers making over $100 million a year on Amazon has roughly tripled over the last several years.
There is an upside for shoppers. Some sellers who come to our Seller Summit do $50 million to $100 million in sales, and when you buy from them, you get a real company you can probably reach on the phone.
Toni worries about the sellers doing under $1 million. Many of them have good products and are still figuring out how much to put on Amazon, and they could easily get squeezed out as everything becomes another payment.
Amazon Haul is growing fast after de minimis ended
Amazon Haul, Amazon’s Temu competitor, is growing fast, and Amazon mentioned it on an earnings call for the first time since launch. I once predicted Haul would die after the de minimis exemption ended, and I was wrong.
Temu got hurt more because it had no US warehouses. When de minimis was abolished, Temu scrambled to find US partners to store and ship inventory, and many of its sellers moved to Amazon.
Amazon now consolidates Haul shipments in China and distributes them to its US warehouses. Toni calls Amazon’s fulfillment network its moat, and she sees new warehouses and Amazon vans everywhere she goes.
I think Haul items are capped at about $20. When I looked for hankies, I found identical items on the main Amazon sold by private label sellers for more, and Amazon is clearly going after the low end and the high end at the same time.
Should new sellers still start on Amazon?
New sellers should still consider starting on Amazon for a launch and quick wins, because you need to see a sale fast. You can do it on your own website, but there are more variables, and you need a good website.
The new ad types make Amazon more complicated for a brand new seller. I know for sure that review ads will be a hit, and I like that they create a cleaner path to reviews than the shady tactics people used before.
I think Amazon’s decision to block outside AI agents will backfire, because product discovery is already moving off Amazon. Younger shoppers start their research on TikTok, AI search, Google, and conversations with friends.
Plenty of older shoppers still order from Amazon every day after doing their research elsewhere and typing in what they want. That is an argument for putting a few products on Amazon, so you show up when shoppers search your brand there.
Frequently asked questions
What are Amazon review ads?
Amazon review ads are a paid ad type where sellers bid to show review requests to customers who already bought their product. Only products with fewer than 1,000 reviews qualify, and Amazon says the ads can triple the review rate.
Are Amazon review ads the same as incentivized reviews?
Amazon review ads are a separate program from incentivized reviews, because the seller pays Amazon for an ad that asks verified buyers for a review. Amazon banned incentivized reviews, where sellers gave away products in exchange for reviews.
What is Amazon branded conversations?
Branded conversations is an Amazon ad type that places sponsored questions under a product listing. Clicking one opens Alexa for Shopping, Amazon’s AI shopping assistant, which answers using the seller’s promoted information.
What happened to Amazon sponsored prompts?
Amazon launched sponsored prompts for free in 2025, and they produced about a 6% conversion lift. Amazon started charging for them in March, and branded conversations is the next version.
Should I connect my Shopify store to Amazon’s multichannel dashboard?
Toni Herrbach and I recommend against connecting your other channels to Amazon’s multichannel dashboard. Amazon competes with its own sellers and has knocked off products before, and the dashboard gives it your sales data from every channel.


