444: The One Mindset Hack That Guarantees Success With Michael Hyatt

Podcast: Download (Duration: 48:14 — 55.5MB)

The fastest way to overcome a limiting belief in business is to run it through a three step process: identify the story you are telling yourself, interrogate whether that story is actually true, and imagine a better story that gets you the result you want. That is the framework Michael Hyatt, New York Times bestselling author and former CEO of a $250 million publishing company, laid out on episode 444 of the My Wife Quit Her Job podcast when we broke down his book Mind Your Mindset.

After more than a decade teaching e-commerce, I have come to the same conclusion Michael has. Strategy is not what holds most of my students back. The story running in their head is.

This post pulls the process out of our conversation, adds the brain science behind why it works, and gives you a worksheet-style example so you can run it on your own biggest limiting belief today.

Get My Free Mini Course On How To Start A Successful Ecommerce Store

If you are interested in starting an ecommerce business, I put together a comprehensive package of resources that will help you launch your own online store from complete scratch. Be sure to grab it before you leave!

Click Here To Download

Key takeaways

• Limiting beliefs are not facts. They are stories your brain wrote to keep you safe, and up to 20 percent of your memories never even happened.
• Michael Hyatt’s three step process is: (1) identify the story, (2) interrogate the story, (3) imagine a better story.
• Your language reveals your thinking. Phrases like “I am not tech savvy” or “I am not good with money” are the first place to look.
• Swapping “have to” for “get to” flips dread into gratitude and is one of the fastest self-corrections you can make.
• Reframe nervous adrenaline as “my body preparing for peak performance” instead of fear, and public speaking gets easier.
• Ask “what would have to be true for this to happen?” whenever a goal feels impossible. It replaces excuses with an action list.
• Who you spend time with matters, because thinking is contagious. Jim Rohn’s rule about the average of the five people you spend the most time with applies to your beliefs, not just your income.

Why limiting beliefs matter more than strategy in business

Limiting beliefs matter more than strategy because your thinking is what selects the strategies you actually try, and those strategies produce your results. If the story running in your head says “I am not the kind of person who can do this,” you will pick smaller strategies, execute them halfheartedly, and quit at the first sign of resistance. The tactics never get a fair test.

Michael put it this way on the show. “Our thinking and our stories are what cause us to select the strategies that we select, and those strategies are what deliver the results we get.”

His conclusion: “If we want better results, extraordinary results, biggie sized results, the best way to do that is to change our thinking, to change the story.”

I have watched this play out inside my own e-commerce course. For years I assumed the class needed better strategy content. The one on one calls with students told a different story.

The students who plateaued had beautiful sites and solid plans. What they lacked was permission to believe the plan would work for them.

The 3-step Mind Your Mindset process for overcoming limiting beliefs

The Mind Your Mindset process has three steps that always run in the same order. You identify the story you are telling yourself, you interrogate whether that story is actually true, and then you imagine a better story that produces the result you want. Michael and his daughter Megan, CEO of Full Focus, developed the framework by pairing brain science with the coaching patterns they saw across hundreds of executive clients.

Here is a snapshot of the three steps before we go deep on each one.

The three steps at a glance

Step 1: Identify the story your narrator is telling you

Step 1 is to catch the exact sentences your brain is repeating about a problem and write them down, because you cannot change a story you have not put into words. Michael calls the voice generating those sentences “the narrator.” It is a personification of your thinking, running nonstop color commentary on everything that happens like a football announcer over the game.

The narrator exists for a reason. “The brain’s number one job is to keep us safe,” Michael said. “So it’s constantly taking the experiences of the past and trying to predict the future and keep us safe.”

That is useful when you are avoiding a hot stove. It is a disaster when the “past experience” was one bad sales call ten years ago.

Two brain-science facts from the book are worth internalizing here. Up to 20 percent of our memories are for events that never actually happened, and up to 70 percent are distorted in some significant way.

Whatever your narrator is quoting as evidence, there is a good chance the evidence is wrong.

How to hear your own narrator

The fastest way to hear your own narrator is to listen to your own language. Every sentence you say out loud is a mirror of a sentence you already said to yourself. Michael’s youngest daughter Marissa has a habit of responding “well, if you say so” whenever someone says something like “I am not a very gifted speaker,” because she knows the speaker is about to prove themselves right.

Michael watched this happen in real time at an industry trade show. A CEO opened a keynote by joking, “hey, I am not a very gifted speaker.” He then spent the next hour proving it. Around 80 percent of the audience had their nose in their phone within minutes.

The two most common limiting beliefs I hear from my e-commerce students

The two limiting beliefs I hear most often from my e-commerce students are “I am not tech savvy enough to build a store” and “I am not good with money.” Both are stories, not facts. Roughly 99 percent of the students who go on to put up beautiful websites in my class started off saying the first sentence. Being tech savvy is really just following directions and learning where to click.

Michael carried the “I am not very good with money” story for a decade after a friend told him that on a plane in the early 1990s, following a business bankruptcy. He accepted it as truth.

“For the next 10 years, I set out to prove the truth of that statement,” he said. The story only broke when he met Dave Ramsey and started swapping it for a new one.

Step 2: Interrogate the story until it admits it is not the truth

Step 2 is to interrogate the story you just wrote down by asking whether it is actually true and, separately, whether it is serving you. A story is a story; it is not the truth.

Most limiting beliefs collapse the moment you put them on paper and read them back to yourself.

Michael’s own introversion story is a clean example. On his Myers-Briggs assessment he scored as an introvert, which he had internalized as “I really do not like people, people wear me out, and I do not like meeting new people.”

His coach Eileen asked one question that reframed the whole thing. “You are the CEO of a public company where you have to meet a lot of new people. How does that construct of introversion serve you?”

The interrogation revealed the story was not fixed. Michael could turn extroversion on when it served him, for example before a keynote when working the crowd made the audience warmer to his message.

He still identifies as an introvert, but the story is now flexible instead of a cage.

Questions to interrogate any limiting belief

Use these questions on any sentence your narrator is running. Write the answers down. You will feel resistance, and that resistance is a signal you are on the right story.

• Is this literally true? What is the evidence, and what is the counter-evidence?
• Is this a fact or an opinion I accepted from someone else?
• How is this story serving me? What am I getting out of believing it?
• Is there a situation where the opposite belief would serve me better?
• What would someone I respect say about this story if they heard it out loud?

Step 3: Imagine a better story that produces the result you want

Step 3 is to rewrite the limiting sentence into a new sentence that is both more accurate and more useful. You are not lying to yourself or slapping affirmations on top of a broken belief. You are choosing a story that gives you agency and points you at the result you want.

Michael’s public speaking reframe is the classic version of Step 3. He used to dread the stage badly enough that he wore two undershirts to hide the sweat.

The rewrite was to focus on the audience instead of himself and to reinterpret his own nervous system. Now when he feels the adrenaline hit, he tells himself, “this is how my body prepares itself for peak performance.”

The science backs the reframe. Adrenaline sharpens focus, speeds thinking, and heightens alertness. It is the same chemical whether you label it “fear” or “peak performance.” The label decides how you use it.

The “have to” vs “get to” swap that changes everything

The single fastest Step 3 rewrite in business is swapping “have to” for “get to” in your own sentences. It is one word. It changes the emotional weight of your entire day.

Michael learned it from a friend who called him on a plane. Michael answered, “I am sitting on a plane because I have to go to San Diego to give a speech.”

His friend laughed. The response, roughly: “Dude, you are going to San Diego, best climate on the planet, awesome fish tacos, you are speaking to a thousand people, and this has been your dream for years.”

Then the reframe: “Nobody is holding a gun to your head. You get to do that.”

Try it on your own week. You do not have to reply to that customer email, you get to; you do not have to ship product tomorrow, you get to.

It sounds trivial, but it rewires how you show up.

The “what would have to be true?” question for impossible goals

When a goal feels impossible, replace “can I do this?” with “what would have to be true for me to do this?” The first question invites your narrator to list objections. The second forces your brain to reverse-engineer an action list.

I brought Michael a live example on the show. My book The Family First Entrepreneur was launching in a few weeks and I had a mental block about hitting the New York Times bestseller list, since coaches kept telling me the odds were single digits.

Michael acknowledged the fact (the Times uses an opaque algorithm, unlike USA Today or the Wall Street Journal, which use raw BookScan sales), then flipped the question.

What would have to be true? Get 50 named endorsements, so he lined up Tony Robbins, John Maxwell, Dave Ramsey and roughly 47 others for Mind Your Mindset. Book 100 podcast interviews, build an amazing sales page, and layer pre-launch and launch-week bonuses.

None of that guarantees the list, but the effort of trying puts you on most of the other lists anyway.

The brain science of why rewriting stories actually works

Rewriting stories works because your brain physically re-wires itself around the sentences you repeat, thanks to a principle called Hebb’s law: “neurons that fire together, wire together.” When your narrator has run the same story for years, those neurons have carved a deep pathway. Every trigger sends the signal down the same groove.

Changing the story means building a new neural pathway on top of the old one. Michael’s metaphor is walking through a field: the old story is the worn footpath through the grass.

The new story is the road less traveled, which feels awkward for the first weeks and then, with enough repetitions, becomes the new natural route.

This is why writing the new sentence down and repeating it out loud matters. Your brain is a computer science problem, and you are re-engineering the code that runs by default. The more reps, the deeper the new groove.

Community and the “average of five” rule

Who you spend time with matters because thinking is contagious. If everyone around you talks about how hard money is or how impossible your industry is, their stories bleed into your narrator. This is exactly why corporate cultures are so hard to turn around once negativity sets in.

Jim Rohn’s often-quoted line is that “you are the average of the five people you spend the most time with.” Whether that is empirically airtight or not, the underlying principle holds. Michael’s version is more specific. If you want to make more money than you are making now, find people who are making a lot of money and study how they think.

He put it bluntly. Elon Musk and Mark Cuban are wickedly smart, and they have deep networks, but the truly load-bearing difference between them and everyone else is how they think about money.

To them another million is “just another zero.” If you can do something that generates $100,000 for your business, the interesting question is why you could not do it for $1 million, $10 million, or $100 million. Most of the answer lives in your thinking.

How to run this process on yourself this week

Sit down with a blank piece of paper today and run the three steps on your single biggest business goal. This is Michael’s exact recommendation and takes about 30 minutes.

• Write down the goal you are stuck on at the top of the page.
• Underneath, write every sentence your narrator says when you think about that goal. Do not edit. Get them out.
• Read each sentence back. Cross out anything obviously silly. Circle the ones that still feel true.
• For each circled sentence, ask “is this literally true?” and “how is this serving me?” Write the answers.
• Rewrite each surviving limiting sentence into a new sentence that is both accurate and empowering. “I am not good with money” becomes “every day I am learning more and more about money.”
• Tape the new sentences somewhere you will see them daily. Give your spouse or a business partner permission to call you out when they hear the old sentence slip back in.

Frequently asked questions

What is a limiting belief in business?

A limiting belief in business is a sentence you have accepted as fact about yourself or your market that makes you avoid, delay, or quit the actions that would produce the result you want. Common examples include “I am not tech savvy enough to build a store,” “I am not good with money,” and “people in my industry never make that much.” They function as truths in your head even when they are opinions someone else handed you.

What are Michael Hyatt’s three steps to overcome limiting beliefs?

Michael Hyatt’s three steps to overcome a limiting belief, from his book Mind Your Mindset, are: (1) identify the exact story you are telling yourself by writing the sentences down, (2) interrogate that story by asking whether it is true and how it is serving you, and (3) imagine a better story that would produce a different result. The book is co-authored with his daughter Megan Hyatt Miller, CEO of Full Focus.

How do I identify the story I am telling myself?

Listen to your own language and write down the exact sentences you repeat when you think about the problem. Pay attention to phrases like “I am not,” “I could never,” “people like me do not,” and “I have to.” Each is a signal that your narrator has scripted a limiting story you have accepted as truth.

How is a limiting belief different from a fact?

A fact is verifiable and stays true regardless of who is looking at it. A limiting belief is an interpretation your brain assigned to a set of facts to keep you safe. Two identical twins raised by alcoholic parents can look at the same facts and produce opposite stories, and one becomes wildly successful while the other repeats the pattern. The facts were the same; the story around them was not.

Does saying “get to” instead of “have to” really change anything?

Yes, because your language shapes your thinking and your thinking selects your actions. Swapping “have to” for “get to” reframes an obligation as a privilege and immediately changes your emotional state around the task. Michael uses it every morning on things he does not particularly enjoy, and it consistently shifts how he shows up.

Why does the “what would have to be true?” question work for impossible goals?

The question redirects your brain from listing objections to reverse-engineering an action plan. Asking “can I hit the New York Times list?” invites your narrator to explain why not. Asking “what would have to be true for me to hit it?” forces you to list endorsements, podcast interviews, launch bonuses, and the specific moves that stack the odds in your favor.

Where can I get Mind Your Mindset by Michael Hyatt?

Mind Your Mindset by Michael Hyatt and Megan Hyatt Miller is available at major retailers including Amazon, and Michael’s launch page at mindyourmindsetbook.com collects the book plus a self-coaching worksheet and reading guide.

Ready To Get Serious About Starting An Online Business?

If you are really considering starting your own online business, then you have to check out my free mini course on How To Create A Niche Online Store In 5 Easy Steps.

In this 6 day mini course, I reveal the steps that my wife and I took to earn 100 thousand dollars in the span of just a year. Best of all, it's absolutely free!