Podcast: Download (Duration: 13:06 — 15.3MB)
To choose the right ecommerce platform for your online store, use the same five-rule framework I use with the students in my Create A Profitable Online Store course: (1) only pick a cart backed by a well-funded, well-known company (or a widely-supported open source project), (2) require deep third-party developer support, (3) demand the platform be easy to maintain, (4) size the true monthly cost including apps, and (5) confirm the built-in blogging platform is good enough to rank in Google. Apply those five filters and your realistic short list collapses to Shopify, BigCommerce, WooCommerce, and Shift4Shop, with the right pick depending on your budget, technical comfort, and how much of your traffic will come from content.
In this solo episode of the My Wife Quit Her Job podcast I answer the single most-asked question I get, which is which ecommerce platform should you use to start an online store. I walk through why I still run my own store on the obsolete OS Commerce cart 17 years after launching Bumblebee Linens, and the exact conditions where I would pick Shopify vs. BigCommerce vs. WooCommerce vs. Shift4Shop.
Below you will find the five rules explained one at a time, a side-by-side comparison of the four platforms I actually recommend, and answers to the questions I get most often about switching, pricing, and SEO.
Get My Free Mini Course On How To Start A Successful Ecommerce Store
If you are interested in starting an ecommerce business, I put together a comprehensive package of resources that will help you launch your own online store from complete scratch. Be sure to grab it before you leave!
Table of Contents
Key takeaways
- The five rules that matter: backer strength, third-party developer support, ease of maintenance, true monthly cost, and blog/SEO quality.
- Never build on a cart run by a two-person startup. If the developers walk away, you inherit an unsupported codebase, which is exactly what happened to me on OS Commerce.
- Applying the five rules leaves you with Shopify, BigCommerce, WooCommerce, and Shift4Shop. Everything else is a compromise on at least one rule.
- Shopify wins on developer ecosystem, loses on true monthly cost. The average Shopify store runs seven paid apps, and my course students average around $200/month in Shopify app spend.
- BigCommerce is the best “get most of what you need out of the box” pick and pairs cleanly with WordPress for SEO through their WordPress plugin.
- WooCommerce is the cheapest and most flexible, but you own the server and every plugin upgrade is your problem.
- Shift4Shop is 100% free once you process $500/month in orders, which makes it the strongest budget alternative to WooCommerce.
Why choosing the right ecommerce platform matters (my $16-hour cautionary tale)
Picking the wrong ecommerce platform locks you into years of pain because migrating a live store to a new cart is one of the hardest technical projects in ecommerce. I know because I have been running my store, Bumblebee Linens, on OS Commerce since 2007, back before Shopify, BigCommerce, Shift4Shop, WooCommerce, or even Amazon Marketplace existed the way they do today.
OS Commerce was the best open source cart of that era and cost me $7 a month to host. It made my family millions of dollars over the years. Then the core developers walked away from the project and it went dead in the water.
By that point I had written so much custom code that migrating to Shopify or BigCommerce would have cost more than maintaining OS Commerce myself. Last month I spent 16 hours of my own time doing a full upgrade to keep it patched. That is the cost of picking a cart that outlives its maintainers.
The 5 rules for choosing an ecommerce platform
Here is the 5-rule framework I use to filter down every ecommerce platform on the market: verify the backer, verify the developer ecosystem, verify it is easy to maintain, verify the true monthly cost, and verify the SEO story. Applied in order, they eliminate 90% of the carts on the market before you have to compare features.
Do not skip a rule to save a decision. Every store I have watched fail on platform choice failed because they weighted price or design ahead of long-term supportability.
Rule 1: Pick a cart backed by a large, well-funded company
Only pick an ecommerce platform run by a well-known, well-funded company with a real war chest of cash, or a popular open source project with thousands of active contributors, because if your platform goes bankrupt or gets abandoned you inherit an unmaintained store overnight. This one rule alone eliminates most of the “cheap” carts people email me about every week.
If a subscriber emails me asking about some free cart I have never heard of, I visit the vendor’s site and almost every time it is a two-person side project. That is a nonstarter. If the founders lose interest or their day jobs get busy, your store dies with the codebase.
A public company is safest because if they go bankrupt someone will buy them and keep the lights on long enough for you to migrate. The open source exception applies when the project has genuine breadth, like WooCommerce or Magento, where thousands of independent developers maintain forks and patches.
Ecommerce carts that pass Rule 1
- Shopify (public company)
- BigCommerce (public company)
- Shift4Shop (backed by Shift4 Payments, public company)
- Square Online (public company)
- Wix (public company)
- Ecwid (owned by Lightspeed, public company)
- Squarespace (public company)
- WooCommerce (owned by Automattic, large open source community)
- Magento / Adobe Commerce (owned by Adobe)
Rule 2: The platform must have deep third-party developer support
Your ecommerce platform must have a large third-party developer ecosystem, because the moment you need a feature the core cart does not offer, you are going to need a plugin, and plugins only get built for the platforms developers can make money on. The two carts with the deepest developer bench today are Shopify and WooCommerce.
Two years from now the norm is going to be an AI shopping assistant embedded in every store. If your platform is not big enough for someone to build that plugin, you will be stuck buying an off-the-shelf widget or waiting on the vendor.
If you look at overall US market share among all shopping carts, Shopify leads, followed by WooCommerce, Wix, Squarespace, and Ecwid. If you filter to the top one million websites in the world by traffic, the picture shifts to WooCommerce and Shopify dominating, with Magento and BigCommerce in the running.
Wix, Square, Squarespace, GoDaddy, and Big Cartel all have large parent companies but do not have meaningful third-party developer ecosystems. The most well-supported ecommerce carts are Shopify, WooCommerce, BigCommerce, and Magento.
Rule 3: The platform has to be easy to maintain
The right ecommerce platform for most non-technical founders is a fully-managed SaaS cart like Shopify or BigCommerce, where the vendor handles servers, security patches, and core software upgrades. Self-hosted platforms like WooCommerce and Magento are more flexible and cheaper, but you are on the hook for the server, the patches, and every broken plugin.
WooCommerce is free but you still pay for hosting, and you still have to lock down your own server against hackers. WordPress and WooCommerce do have a push-button upgrade flow, but bad things happen. A couple of weeks ago I upgraded my Bumblebee Linens WordPress blog and a bunch of plugins broke and I had to hand-debug what went wrong.
The upside of owning the source code is total flexibility. On my store I let customers see a mockup of the finished personalized product before checkout, and no plugin does that. WooCommerce let me write it myself.
If you have zero interest in maintaining a server or debugging plugin conflicts, this rule alone narrows your list to Shopify or BigCommerce.
Rule 4: The platform has to be reasonably priced (true monthly cost)
The true monthly cost of an ecommerce platform is base subscription + required apps + payment processing markup, and Shopify’s true monthly cost is much higher than its $30 sticker because the core cart is deliberately thin on features and nearly every store ends up paying for seven or more apps. The typical Shopify user in my Create A Profitable Online Store course spends around $200 a month on Shopify apps alone.
BigCommerce ships with most of what you actually need out of the box, so you do not get nickel-and-dimed the same way. Shift4Shop is a genuine outlier because the shopping cart is roughly as powerful as BigCommerce and Shopify, and it is 100% free as long as you process at least $500 a month in orders through their payment processor.
WooCommerce is 100% free to run, WordPress has thousands of free plugins for it, and your only fixed cost is hosting. If price is your primary constraint, WooCommerce, Shift4Shop, and BigCommerce are the three carts you should short-list.
Ecommerce platform true monthly cost comparison
| Platform | Base plan | Typical add-on cost | Realistic monthly total |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shopify | $39 (Basic) | ~$200 in apps (per my course avg) | ~$240+ |
| BigCommerce | $39 (Standard) | Minimal, most features in-platform | ~$40-$60 |
| WooCommerce | $0 software | $25-$100 hosting, mostly free plugins | ~$25-$100 |
| Shift4Shop | $0 (with $500+/mo processing) | None required | $0 (payment processing only) |
Rule 5: The platform must have a good blogging platform for SEO
If organic search traffic is going to be a meaningful channel for your store, pick a platform with a genuinely capable, WordPress-grade blog engine. Shopify’s built-in blog is not that. It is limited in features and has a suboptimal URL structure that hurts ranking.
WooCommerce has the best built-in blog by a wide margin because it is literally WordPress. BigCommerce is the smart middle ground because their WordPress plugin lets you run your store on BigCommerce and your blog on WordPress under the same subdomain, so you get store-quality checkout plus WordPress-grade SEO.
If SEO is a top-three channel in your business plan, this rule alone collapses your list to WooCommerce or BigCommerce paired with WordPress.
Which ecommerce platform is best for me? (my picks by use case)
Below is how I actually match the four short-listed platforms to real founder situations. Every recommendation assumes you have already passed the first two rules (real backer, real developer support).
| Your situation | Best platform | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Budget is not a constraint and you want the largest app ecosystem | Shopify | Best third-party developer ecosystem in ecommerce. You will pay for it in apps, but every new feature ships on Shopify first. |
| You want a solid, feature-complete cart without paying for apps | BigCommerce | Most of what Shopify charges you for is included. Pairs with WordPress for SEO through the official plugin. |
| You want maximum flexibility and are (or can hire) technically comfortable | WooCommerce | Own the source code. Cheapest to run. Best built-in blog. You are on the hook for the server. |
| You want a strict $0 budget and process $500+/month | Shift4Shop | 100% free with the required processing volume, and roughly as capable as BigCommerce. |
| Content and SEO are core to your growth plan | BigCommerce + WordPress, or WooCommerce | Both give you a WordPress-grade blog engine, which Shopify does not offer. |
How hard is it to switch ecommerce platforms later?
Migrating an established store to a new ecommerce platform is painful, expensive, and disruptive to search rankings, which is why platform choice matters much more than most first-time founders realize. Product data and customer records port cleanly. Custom functionality, URL structures, and search rankings do not.
Every custom feature you build on top of your platform is technical debt that has to be reimplemented on the new cart. Every URL that changes during migration is a redirect you have to set up correctly or you lose the SEO equity that URL had accumulated. Every checkout flow that changes is a conversion risk.
Get the choice right the first time and you can grow on the same platform for a decade. Get it wrong and you either eat a painful migration or, like me, get stuck maintaining a cart that has outlived its maintainers.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best ecommerce platform for beginners?
For most non-technical beginners, BigCommerce is the best pick because it includes most of the features you need out of the box, does not require you to maintain a server, and pairs with WordPress for content marketing through an official plugin. Shopify is a very close second and wins on app ecosystem, but the true monthly cost climbs faster.
Is Shopify or WooCommerce better for a new online store?
Shopify is better if you want zero server maintenance and the deepest app ecosystem, and you are comfortable spending around $200 a month on plugins on top of the base plan. WooCommerce is better if you want full flexibility, own your source code, need a serious blog engine for SEO, and are comfortable maintaining your own hosting.
How much does it really cost to run a Shopify store?
The typical Shopify store in my Create A Profitable Online Store course spends around $200 a month on Shopify apps on top of the base plan, because Shopify ships intentionally lean and charges for common features like advanced shipping rules, subscriptions, and reviews. Budget $240 to $300 per month all-in for a starter Shopify store, plus payment processing fees.
Is Shift4Shop really free?
Shift4Shop is 100% free as long as you process at least $500 a month in orders through Shift4 Payments, their in-house payment processor. Below that threshold, you either pay a monthly fee or accept payment processing charges as your only cost.
Which ecommerce platform is best for SEO?
WooCommerce is the strongest ecommerce platform for SEO because it runs on WordPress, which has the deepest blogging feature set and cleanest URL control. BigCommerce paired with the WordPress plugin is the strongest hosted alternative because you get BigCommerce checkout plus a full WordPress blog under the same domain.
Should I ever pick Wix, Square Online, or Squarespace for an ecommerce store?
Wix, Square Online, and Squarespace all pass Rule 1 on backer strength but fail Rule 2 on developer support, because independent developers do not build many meaningful ecommerce plugins for these platforms. They can work for very simple, small-catalog stores, but they will constrain you as you grow.
What happens if my ecommerce platform shuts down?
If your ecommerce platform shuts down, you either have to migrate every product, customer, and URL to a new cart, or maintain the software yourself, which is why Rule 1 matters. This is exactly what happened to me on OS Commerce, and 17 years later I am still doing occasional 16-hour maintenance upgrades because migrating was worse than staying.
I Need Your Help
If you enjoyed listening to this podcast, then please support me with a review on Apple Podcasts. It's easy and takes 1 minute! Just click here to head to Apple Podcasts and leave an honest rating and review of the podcast. Every review helps!
Ready To Get Serious About Starting An Online Business?
If you are really considering starting your own online business, then you have to check out my free mini course on How To Create A Niche Online Store In 5 Easy Steps.
In this 6 day mini course, I reveal the steps that my wife and I took to earn 100 thousand dollars in the span of just a year. Best of all, it's absolutely free!
