Podcast: Download (Duration: 46:11 — 52.9MB)
The most profitable way to sell on Etsy today is print on demand, using the same launch playbook that works on Amazon: a heavily discounted launch price, Etsy ads to force sales velocity, and an email list you own so you can hit the same customer at every Q4 holiday. Print on demand blanket-style products routinely sell for 79 to 89 dollars with roughly 40 percent margins, and around 80 percent of a typical Etsy seller’s annual revenue lands between November and December.
In this episode of the My Wife Quit Her Job podcast, I sit down with Scott Voelker of Brand Creators, one of the original Amazon podcasters, whose wife Debbie now runs a thriving print on demand Etsy shop that Scott helps market. Scott has interviewed the number-one jewelry seller on Etsy (over 2 million sales) and reviewed dozens of six and seven figure shops, so the numbers and tactics below are pulled directly from what he sees working.
Here is the full playbook: what to sell, how to rank a new listing, how Etsy ads actually work, and how to squeeze the most repeat revenue out of the email tools Etsy quietly added in 2023.
Get My Free Mini Course On How To Start A Successful Ecommerce Store
If you are interested in starting an ecommerce business, I put together a comprehensive package of resources that will help you launch your own online store from complete scratch. Be sure to grab it before you leave!
Table of Contents
Key takeaways
- Etsy has roughly 7.5 million sellers and 95 to 100 million buyers, and it is dominated by gift-giving, so around 80 percent of most sellers’ annual revenue lands in Q4.
- Print on demand (sweatshirts, pillows, flags, ornaments, blankets) counts as handmade on Etsy as long as you design the artwork yourself. Blankets sell for 79 to 89 dollars with about 40 percent margins.
- The launch formula is Amazon-style: launch the listing, discount 40 percent for a week, run Etsy ads at 25 dollars a day, email your list, and force sales velocity so the algorithm ranks you.
- Etsy ads have almost no knobs. You pick listings and a daily budget. The real value is using the search-term report to add negative keywords and see which queries actually convert.
- Since September 6, 2023, Etsy’s Share and Save program refunds 4 percent of your Etsy fees on any sale you drive yourself with your own traffic.
- Etsy now lets you email customers legally with integrations like AWeber and Everbee. You get consent through the order-status flow, then own the subscriber and can export the list any time.
- Canva Pro (not Photoshop) plus Creative Fabrica for fonts and elements, and the occasional Fiverr designer, is the entire design stack Debbie uses.
How big is Etsy in 2024 and how much can a print on demand shop make?
Etsy has around 7.5 million sellers and 95 to 100 million active buyers, which is roughly a thousand times smaller than Amazon on the seller side but still a massive gift-focused marketplace where six and seven figure shops are common. Scott interviewed the number-one Etsy jewelry seller who has done over 2 million sales, largely on Etsy alone until adding Shopify in 2021, and now employs about 30 people.
For print on demand specifically, Scott estimates his wife Debbie’s shop could scale to seven figures if they pushed it, and they intentionally cap it because they prefer the lifestyle. A typical benchmark he shared: a first serious Q4 for a new shop can land in the 20,000 to 30,000 dollar range, with veteran million-dollar sellers doing 400,000 to 500,000 dollars in November alone.
The catch on revenue potential is customer support. Print on demand almost always includes personalization (dates, names, monograms), which means real customers with real mistakes and real refund requests. Even with a third-party printer like Printify, you cannot run this fully unattended.
Why Etsy is still an “untapped” marketing channel
Scott’s core argument is that most Etsy sellers do not do any external marketing. They list products, hope the search algorithm favors them, and never build an email list, run ads, or drive outside traffic. Anyone applying standard Amazon or Shopify marketing tactics on Etsy has an enormous edge.
That is why Scott shifted his teaching focus from Amazon to Etsy at Brand Creators. The playbook is nearly identical to what worked on Amazon in the early days, and almost nobody on Etsy is doing it.
What can you actually sell on Etsy with print on demand?
Print on demand on Etsy means sweatshirts, t-shirts, pillows, garden and yard flags, stockings, ornaments, and blankets, all counted as “handmade” so long as you design the artwork yourself. Etsy is actively cracking down on true dropshipping (reselling generic products with no design work), but print on demand where you own the design is fully allowed.
Blankets are one of the strongest categories Scott flagged. A fleece-style blanket with a full one-side print can sell for 79 to 89 dollars with about 40 percent margins, and the listing costs 20 cents for three months whether or not it sells. That is essentially free shelf space with high-ticket upside.
The other reason print on demand fits Etsy so well is that one design multiplies into five products. The same artwork gets loaded onto a pillow, a flag, a blanket, a shirt, and a mug, so a single day of Debbie’s design work spawns a week of listings.
How do you rank a new print on demand listing on Etsy?
You rank a new Etsy listing by forcing sales velocity in the first week, using the same launch tactic that used to work on Amazon: launch at a 40 percent discount, run Etsy ads at 25 dollars a day, email your list to hit the discount, and let the sales spike train Etsy’s algorithm to promote your listing organically. Etsy, like every marketplace, promotes what is already selling.
The mistake Scott sees most new sellers make is “list it and pray.” A perfect SEO title with zero sales history will lose to a mediocre listing with 50 sales in a week, every time. If 50 nearly identical listings exist for the same product, sales velocity is the tiebreaker Etsy actually uses.
Reviews compound on top of that spike. Discounted launch buyers leave reviews, reviews raise conversion rate on future traffic, and higher conversion rate feeds back into the algorithm, all from one aggressive launch week.
Keyword research: use the top-selling listing, not just the tool
Everbee (the Chrome extension for Etsy) is the standard keyword and tag tool, but Scott treats its search-volume numbers as guesses, not truth. His actual research move is to look at the products already selling for the term he wants to rank for, then reverse-engineer their titles and tags.
Everbee can expose a competitor’s 13 backend tags, so you see the exact phrases that are driving sales for the top listing. That is far higher signal than any keyword volume estimate.
One live example he shared: a student was crushing a rustic-wood Christmas Advent sign on TikTok but selling nothing on Etsy. The fix was adding “farmhouse Christmas decoration” to the title, because “farmhouse” is a high-volume Etsy term and her existing title had missed it.
How do Etsy ads work compared to Amazon sponsored ads?
Etsy ads are dramatically simpler than Amazon PPC: you pick which listings to promote and set a daily budget (Scott runs around 25 dollars a day), and that is essentially every control you get. You cannot bid on specific keywords, you cannot exclude products, and you cannot set placement rules.
The one lever you do have is negative keywords on the back end. Etsy shows you which search terms drove clicks to your listing, and you can turn off any query that is irrelevant. For a rustic Christmas sign, that meant killing the generic term “wood” and keeping only Christmas-specific queries.
The reporting is intentionally limited. You see impressions, clicks, orders, and revenue, but Etsy does not deduct your product cost from ROAS.
A reported 15 percent ROAS looks good until you subtract product cost and shipping and realize you broke even. Do that math yourself before you scale spend.
Why running Etsy ads may boost organic rankings too
Scott’s hunch, which matches what many Etsy sellers report, is that running Etsy ads gives you a small organic lift. The reasoning is that Etsy interprets ad spend as “this is a real, serious business,” and rewards it with a nudge on the organic side. There is no confirmation from Etsy, but the correlation is consistent enough that Scott treats ads as both a sales channel and a ranking signal.
How to use Etsy’s built-in email offers to lift conversion
Etsy has three built-in coupon triggers that email buyers on your behalf, using the shopper’s real Etsy inbox and requiring zero email address collection: a “favorited an item” coupon, an “abandoned cart” coupon, and a “post-purchase thank you” coupon. All three are configured inside your Etsy shop and cost nothing to run.
The favorites and cart triggers require a coupon (Scott tested 5 percent, then bumped it to 10 percent because the higher discount converted better). The post-purchase thank-you coupon commonly runs at 20 percent to seed a second order. Etsy reports how many emails were sent and how many sales converted, so you can see exact ROI.
The 90-day retroactive email trick most sellers miss
There is a hidden option most Etsy sellers do not know about: if you turn off a coupon trigger and then turn it back on with a new discount, Etsy will ask if you want to send the new offer to customers from the previous 90 days who favorited or cart-added but did not buy. That is a free retroactive campaign to a warm, product-specific list.
Scott plans to use this every year right after the holidays: raise the favorites coupon from 5 percent to 10 percent, then flip the retroactive box and hit 90 days of Q4 window-shoppers at once.
How to legally collect Etsy customer emails and own the list
Etsy explicitly allows you to email customers about their orders, and you can use those order emails to invite them to opt in to a VIP list you own. AWeber has been the official Etsy email integration for years, and Everbee Email launched in 2023 as a more modern one-click alternative built for Etsy shops.
The compliant flow is: order confirmation email includes a “join our VIP club for early access to new designs” link, the buyer double opts in, and now they are a real email subscriber you control. From there you can export the list to ConvertKit, Klaviyo, or any provider, or keep them in Everbee and email straight from there.
Everbee also pulls your product catalog into the footer of order emails so you can cross-sell your best sellers on every shipping notification. That single addition is a free lift on your average order value.
Etsy Share and Save: the 4 percent fee refund most sellers miss
On September 6, 2023, Etsy launched the Share and Save program, which refunds 4 percent of your Etsy transaction fees on any sale you drive with your own traffic (email, social, blog, ads). Scott ran a case study in October and generated roughly 3,100 dollars from email, which returned about 140 to 150 dollars in fee refunds on top of the sale, essentially free profit for traffic he was already sending.
The signal from Etsy is clear: they want you driving external traffic, and they are willing to pay you to do it. Combine Share and Save with an email list you own and every campaign has an extra 4 percent margin baked in.
How Debbie designs 5 products from 1 idea using Canva
The entire design stack for Debbie’s shop is Canva Pro plus Creative Fabrica for fonts and design elements, with occasional custom illustration work bought on Fiverr. Scott (a longtime Photoshop user) has fully retired Photoshop from his current laptop, because Canva handles every print on demand design job faster.
Cadence matters more than tool choice. Heading into Q4, Debbie pushes roughly one new design per day, and each design gets deployed across five products (pillow, flag, blanket, shirt, mug), so one design day equals five new listings. That output level is what stocks the shop for gift-buying traffic.
Themes rotate seasonally: Christmas heavy from October through December, then Easter and spring in February and March, Mother’s and Father’s Day into May and June, and fall and Halloween from August. The catalog compounds, so evergreen designs (a well-selling Christmas sign) still sell in July when the algorithm surfaces them to gift shoppers.
Do you need AI for Etsy print on demand designs?
Not really, yet. Debbie has experimented with AI art tools and has not found them essential for the personalization-heavy designs she sells. For SVG-driven categories (die-cut signs, layered vinyl) Creative Fabrica still wins on both price and license clarity.
That said, AI is worth testing for on-demand concept ideation and for generating backgrounds and textures. It is a supplement to Canva, not a replacement for the design taste that makes a shop sell.
The step by step launch playbook for a new Etsy print on demand product
Here is the compressed version of Scott’s launch playbook for a new print on demand listing, in the order to execute it.
- Design the artwork in Canva Pro. Deploy the same design across five product formats (shirt, pillow, flag, blanket, mug).
- Research the top-selling competing listing with Everbee. Copy the title structure and back-end tags that are actually driving sales.
- Set the launch price 40 percent below the intended price, and label it as a launch special in the listing copy.
- Turn on Etsy ads for the new listings at roughly 25 dollars per day, split across the five formats.
- Email your list on day one with the discount and a hard deadline (this week only).
- Turn on all three Etsy built-in coupon triggers (favorites at 10 percent, cart-abandon at 15 percent, thank-you at 20 percent).
- After 7 days, raise the price to full retail. The listing should now have enough reviews and sales velocity for organic traffic to take over.
- Once orders start flowing, use the order-status email flow to invite buyers to your VIP email list. Own that list going forward.
Frequently asked questions
Is print on demand allowed on Etsy in 2024?
Yes, print on demand is allowed on Etsy as long as you are the designer of the artwork applied to the product. Etsy is cracking down on generic dropshipping (reselling unmodified third-party products), but original designs printed by a third-party fulfiller like Printify count as handmade under Etsy’s rules.
How much can you make on Etsy with print on demand?
Print on demand Etsy shops routinely do six figures a year, and the top of the market is well into seven figures. Scott’s wife’s shop hit 20,000 to 30,000 dollars in her first serious Q4, and Scott interviewed one seller doing 400,000 to 500,000 dollars in November alone.
How much do Etsy ads cost and are they worth it?
Etsy ads are usually run at a fixed daily budget (25 dollars a day is a common starting point), and cost per click is typically much lower than Amazon sponsored ads. They are worth running mainly for the sales velocity and search-term data, since the reporting does not deduct product cost from ROAS and you must do that math yourself.
What is Etsy’s Share and Save program?
Etsy’s Share and Save program, launched September 6, 2023, refunds 4 percent of your Etsy transaction fees on any sale you drive with your own outside traffic. Every email, ad, or social post you send that results in a sale earns you a 4 percent fee credit, effectively boosting margin on all self-driven sales.
Can you legally collect Etsy customer emails?
Yes, Etsy allows you to email customers about their order and to invite them to opt in to a separate marketing list, as long as buyers give explicit double-opt-in consent. Integrations like AWeber and Everbee Email automate the opt-in flow and let you export the list to any email provider.
What is the best design tool for Etsy print on demand?
Canva Pro is the most common design tool for Etsy print on demand sellers today, and it has replaced Photoshop for most everyday design work. Sellers often pair it with Creative Fabrica for fonts and design elements, and occasionally hire custom illustrations on Fiverr.
Why does Q4 dominate Etsy sales so much?
Etsy is fundamentally a gift-buying marketplace, so roughly 80 percent of an average seller’s annual revenue lands in November and December. Weddings, Mother’s Day, Father’s Day, and other gift-heavy holidays make up most of the remaining seasonality.
I Need Your Help
If you enjoyed listening to this podcast, then please support me with a review on Apple Podcasts. It's easy and takes 1 minute! Just click here to head to Apple Podcasts and leave an honest rating and review of the podcast. Every review helps!
Ready To Get Serious About Starting An Online Business?
If you are really considering starting your own online business, then you have to check out my free mini course on How To Create A Niche Online Store In 5 Easy Steps.
In this 6 day mini course, I reveal the steps that my wife and I took to earn 100 thousand dollars in the span of just a year. Best of all, it's absolutely free!
