562: US Sellers Rejoice! The Govt Just Destroyed Temu And Shein

Podcast: Download (Duration: 14:08 — 16.5MB)

The de minimis crackdown announced by the Biden administration on September 13, 2024 removes the tariff-free import loophole that let Temu and Shein undercut US sellers on price, and it does so in three ways at once. First, products covered by Section 301, 232, or 201 tariffs no longer qualify for the $800 de minimis exemption, which affects roughly 70 percent of what Temu and Shein sell into the US.

Second, sellers now must supply a 10-digit tariff classification and the buyer’s identifying information (potentially a Social Security number) for every de minimis shipment. Third, all consumer-good importers must file a certificate of compliance with US safety regulations at time of entry, closing the loophole that let unsafe children’s toys, chargers, cosmetics, and textiles slip through untested.

For US ecommerce sellers, this is the biggest structural leveling of the playing field with Chinese direct-to-consumer platforms in a decade. Temu was already losing an average of $30 per US order, PDD Holdings just lost about $55 billion of market cap in a single day, and Temu suppliers are staging sit-ins in Guangzhou over unpaid balances. Rule changes that push retail prices up will accelerate all three trends.

Below I walk through the three advantages Temu leveraged to dominate US ecommerce, why every one of them has now collapsed, exactly what changed in the de minimis rules, and what US sellers should expect over the next 12 to 24 months.

Get My Free Mini Course On How To Start A Successful Ecommerce Store

If you are interested in starting an ecommerce business, I put together a comprehensive package of resources that will help you launch your own online store from complete scratch. Be sure to grab it before you leave!

Click Here To Download

Key takeaways

• Temu was losing about $30 per US order and roughly $588 to $954 million per year, subsidized by PDD Holdings, which has a market cap near $179 billion.
• PDD stock dropped over 28 percent in one day (about $55 billion of market cap) after missing quarterly revenue estimates and a bearish outlook.
• The de minimis change removes tariff-free entry for goods covered by Section 301, 232, or 201, which together cover about 70 percent of Temu and Shein’s US-sold catalog.
• Sellers now must file a 10-digit HTS code and buyer identifying information (Social Security number or EIN) for every low-value shipment claiming de minimis.
• All consumer goods must arrive with an electronically filed certificate of compliance, blocking untested items that violate US safety regulations.
• Temu suppliers held a sit-in in Guangzhou; one seller reported roughly 2 million yuan (about $276,000) in payments frozen by Temu.
• Effectiveness depends on enforcement, and full CBP operational rollout will likely take 12 to 24 months.

What is the de minimis rule and why did Temu depend on it?

The de minimis rule allowed any shipment valued at $800 or less to enter the United States free of import duties and tariffs, which let Temu and Shein ship packages direct from Chinese factories to US buyers without paying the tariffs a US-based importer would pay. That single exemption is what made a $5 t-shirt or a $12 phone case possible at Temu prices. Every US ecommerce brand importing full container loads has been paying Section 301 tariffs (often 7.5 percent to 25 percent) on the same goods.

The threshold was raised from $200 to $800 in 2016 to speed up small package customs. Chinese direct-to-consumer platforms then built entire business models on top of it, splitting inventory into individual $10 to $30 parcels and shipping them one at a time to US buyers.

The volume grew fast. US Customs and Border Protection processed roughly 1 billion de minimis shipments in fiscal 2023, more than three times the volume in 2019.

The three advantages that let Temu dominate US ecommerce

Temu’s US dominance rested on three specific structural advantages, and every one of them has now weakened or disappeared. Understanding each one is the fastest way to see why the new rules are so damaging in combination.

• A billion-dollar sugar daddy. PDD Holdings (Pinduoduo), Temu’s parent, has a market cap near $179 billion and used it to subsidize aggressive US pricing.
• A desperate seller base. Slower Chinese domestic ecommerce demand pushed thousands of Chinese manufacturers onto Temu at whatever margin the platform demanded.
• The de minimis loophole. Sub-$800 shipments avoided tariffs entirely, giving Temu a structural 10 to 25 percent price advantage over any US importer.

Why PDD Holdings can no longer subsidize Temu

PDD Holdings can no longer bankroll Temu’s losses because its own business is deteriorating fast. In August 2024, PDD grossly missed quarterly revenue estimates and Chinese executives gave pessimistic remarks about domestic ecommerce and PDD’s global outlook. The stock dropped over 28 percent in a single day, marking the largest one-day decline in company history and erasing about $55 billion in market cap.

Temu’s own unit economics are ugly. Wired reported that Temu was losing about $30 per US order, and China Merchants Securities estimated total US losses at $588 million to $954 million per year.

The influencer spend has visibly dried up too. I used to receive constant sponsored-content requests from Temu; over the past few months the activity has stopped almost entirely. Whether they run a Super Bowl ad again in 2026 will be the next real signal.

Why Temu’s Chinese sellers are revolting

Temu’s Chinese sellers are staging sit-ins because Temu’s price-squeeze model has left them unable to make a profit and frequently unable to withdraw their earnings. Hundreds of Temu suppliers recently demonstrated at a Temu-affiliated office in Guangzhou over unfair fines and withheld payments. One household-goods seller reported about 2 million yuan (roughly $276,000) in completed-sale proceeds that Temu had frozen.

The mechanic is punishing by design. Temu regularly demands sellers lower their prices, and if the seller refuses, Temu simply removes the product from the marketplace. If the seller agrees, Temu often lowers the price without disclosing the new number in advance, leaving the seller to discover it after the fact.

China tech analyst Ivy Yang of Wavelet Strategy has said the discontent has been brewing for a while and has finally reached a tipping point. When the underlying supplier base breaks, catalog quality and fulfillment reliability go with it.

What changed in the new de minimis rules (September 13, 2024)

The Biden administration’s September 13, 2024 announcement introduces three specific changes to how de minimis shipments enter the United States, and each one hits Temu and Shein’s model directly. Together they close the loophole for the categories those platforms rely on and add compliance friction to every remaining shipment.

Change 1: Section 301, 232, and 201 tariff goods lose the exemption

Any product subject to Section 301, 232, or 201 tariffs is now excluded from the $800 de minimis exemption, so those shipments owe both customs duties and full tariff rates regardless of parcel size. Section 301 tariffs cover electronics, textiles, and machinery; Section 232 covers steel, aluminum, and related materials; Section 201 covers solar panels and washing machines. Together those categories represent about 40 percent of total US imports from China and roughly 70 percent of what Temu and Shein sell into the US.

Prices on affected items will move to full-tariff-inclusive levels overnight once enforcement is in effect. The 10 to 25 percent effective price increase on most Temu and Shein SKUs erases most of the platform’s headline price advantage over Amazon, Walmart, and US direct-to-consumer brands.

Change 2: Stricter information collection on every de minimis shipment

Every low-value shipment claiming the de minimis exemption must now include a 10-digit HTS tariff classification number and buyer identifying information, which lets US Customs and Border Protection flag or duty items that should not have qualified. When goods are imported for personal use above certain thresholds, the buyer normally provides a Social Security number or EIN. Under the new rules, that requirement can flow through to individual Temu and Shein customers.

Almost no US consumer will hand a Chinese ecommerce app their Social Security number to save $3 on a t-shirt. Existing paranoia about Chinese data collection alone will kill conversion the day the field appears.

If the US chooses to enforce this rule aggressively, it functionally shuts down direct-to-consumer parcel flow from Temu and Shein to US buyers on any covered item.

Change 3: Certificates of compliance required at entry

All importers of consumer goods must now electronically file a certificate of compliance at time of entry, even for de minimis shipments, closing the loophole that let Chinese platforms ship products that failed US safety regulations. The Consumer Product Safety Commission gains real ability to block non-compliant items. This is the change that directly targets the safety-scandal categories Temu and Shein have gotten away with for years.

Concrete examples the rule targets:

• Children’s toys shipped with unsafe levels of lead, phthalates, and other harmful chemicals.
• Counterfeit phone chargers and power banks without mandatory UL certification, creating fire and shock risk.
• Shein-sold textiles and clothing containing formaldehyde or azo dyes linked to skin and allergic reactions.
• Cosmetics containing mercury or hydroquinone with documented long-term toxicity risk.
• Children’s apparel and cribs failing US flammability and choking hazard tests.

Consumers who buy uncertified items may themselves be asked to file a certificate of compliance. In practice, almost nobody will do that, which functionally blocks the item.

Temu and Shein price impact: how much will bargains actually rise?

Expected price impact on Temu and Shein US listings is roughly 10 to 25 percent on affected SKUs once the tariff exemption is removed, with additional friction from the new documentation and safety-certification requirements. That range mirrors the underlying Section 301 tariff rates that will now apply. On lowest-margin items (apparel, home goods, small electronics), the increase is often the whole difference between “half of Amazon” and “same as Amazon.”

The knock-on effect is even larger than the sticker price move. Once Temu is no longer meaningfully cheaper than Amazon, its core value proposition (“shop like a billionaire”) disappears and the platform reverts to a slow-shipping Chinese marketplace with an unfamiliar brand.

Shein faces the same math with worse category exposure. Apparel is entirely inside the affected tariff categories.

What this means for US ecommerce sellers

US ecommerce sellers gain the biggest structural pricing tailwind in a decade because the tariff arbitrage that let Chinese direct-to-consumer platforms undercut them is going away. If you sell any category with meaningful Temu or Shein competition (small home goods, apparel, phone accessories, kitchen gadgets, kids items), you should expect measurable share recapture over the next 12 to 24 months as enforcement ramps up.

Concrete actions to consider now:

• Audit your top-selling SKUs for Temu and Shein listings. Note the current price gap. Model what happens to Temu’s price at plus 15 to 25 percent.
• Refresh product photography, listing copy, and reviews on Amazon, Shopify, and Walmart. Buyers migrating away from Temu will search on their most familiar platforms first.
• Lean into US safety compliance in your marketing. CPSC-tested, UL-listed, and FDA-registered claims mean more the moment consumers realize Temu was skipping them.
• Consider raising prices modestly on any SKU where you have been under-earning to match Temu. Recovered margin funds ad spend and inventory.

How fast will the new de minimis rules actually take effect?

Effective enforcement of the new de minimis rules will likely take 12 to 24 months to reach steady state because CBP has to update systems, issue final regulations, and staff for the increased inspection workload. The September 13, 2024 announcement was a proposed regulatory change, and the formal rulemaking process (notice, comment, final rule, and effective date) typically runs 6 to 18 months on its own. Serious enforcement follows that.

I still expect early aggressive enforcement to set an example. Regulators typically pursue high-visibility actions in the first 6 to 12 months of a new rule to establish precedent, and Temu is the highest-visibility target imaginable.

Sellers should not assume slow rollout means no impact. Even the threat of enforcement plus voluntary compliance from major carriers has already moved prices in some Temu categories.

Frequently asked questions

What is the de minimis rule?

The de minimis rule is a US customs provision that allowed shipments valued at $800 or less to enter the country free of duties and tariffs. It was designed to speed up small package customs but became the loophole Chinese direct-to-consumer platforms used to ship tariff-free to US buyers.

Will Temu prices go up because of the new de minimis rules?

Yes. Temu prices on tariff-affected goods will rise by roughly 10 to 25 percent once the new de minimis rules are enforced, because Section 301, 232, and 201 tariffs will now apply to those shipments. Roughly 70 percent of Temu’s US-sold catalog falls in the affected categories.

Will I have to give Temu my Social Security number?

Under the new rules, buyers of items above certain personal-use thresholds may need to provide a Social Security number or EIN to claim the de minimis exemption. Almost no US consumer is expected to hand a Chinese app their Social Security number, so the practical effect is that affected items will simply carry duties and tariffs like normal imports.

Are Temu products actually unsafe?

Regulators and independent testers have found multiple categories of unsafe Temu and Shein products, including children’s toys with elevated lead and phthalate levels, uncertified phone chargers and power banks with fire risk, and textiles containing formaldehyde and azo dyes. The new certificate of compliance requirement is designed to keep those items out of the US market.

Is Shein affected by the same de minimis rules?

Yes. Shein is affected by the same de minimis changes as Temu, and its apparel-heavy catalog falls almost entirely inside the Section 301 tariff categories that now lose the exemption. The tariff exposure on Shein is arguably greater than on Temu.

Will US ecommerce sellers benefit from the de minimis crackdown?

US ecommerce sellers will benefit because the crackdown removes a 10 to 25 percent structural price advantage that Temu and Shein have enjoyed for years. Sellers competing in the same categories should expect share recapture on Amazon, Shopify, and Walmart over the next 12 to 24 months.

When will the new rules actually take effect?

The September 13, 2024 announcement kicked off a formal rulemaking process that typically runs 6 to 18 months before final rules take effect, with full operational enforcement likely taking 12 to 24 months. Early high-visibility enforcement actions are likely once the rules are final.

Ready To Get Serious About Starting An Online Business?

If you are really considering starting your own online business, then you have to check out my free mini course on How To Create A Niche Online Store In 5 Easy Steps.

In this 6 day mini course, I reveal the steps that my wife and I took to earn 100 thousand dollars in the span of just a year. Best of all, it's absolutely free!