608: Why Most Amazon Sellers Will Fail In 2025 (And What Winners Do Differently) With Norm Farrar

Podcast: Download (Duration: 53:01 — 61.0MB)

The reason most Amazon sellers will fail in 2025 is that they are still running 2017 tactics (keyword-stuffed titles, thin bullets, weak brand, and zero owned audience) while the winning sellers are building off-Amazon communities via newsletters, WhatsApp groups, and referral loops so they never have to compete on price on the marketplace. On this episode of the My Wife Quit Her Job podcast, I sat down with Norm Farrar, host of Lunch With Norm and Marketing Misfits, longtime advisor to seven and eight figure brands, and co-owner of a family manufacturing operation in China, to walk through the exact community-building system he is deploying on client brands right now.

Norm has trashed hundreds of listings live on his podcast and helped hundreds of sellers scale, and his conclusion is that the biggest gap between sellers who make it and sellers who fail is not the product. It is the community around the product.

Below is his full playbook: how to build a brand community when you sell on Amazon, the newsletter and referral system that scales it, which platform to use (Facebook vs WhatsApp vs Discord), the Google knowledge panel move that most sellers ignore, and how to structure your team so the community runs without you.

Get My Free Mini Course On How To Start A Successful Ecommerce Store

If you are interested in starting an ecommerce business, I put together a comprehensive package of resources that will help you launch your own online store from complete scratch. Be sure to grab it before you leave!

Click Here To Download

Key takeaways

• The single biggest reason Amazon sellers fail in 2025 is running outdated 2017 tactics (keyword-stuffed titles, weak bullets, weak brand, and zero owned audience) instead of building a community that pulls demand off-Amazon.
• Norm’s newsletter now generates more leads than his podcast. He would have built it years earlier if he had known.
• The best community starter is a lifetime warranty plus a recurring value asset (Norm’s knife client uses a weekly meal plan) delivered from a QR code on the product packaging.
• WhatsApp has outperformed Facebook Groups for engagement on Norm’s own community. Facebook Groups still work for niche recipe-and-hobby groups where content sharing is native.
• Norm uses Beehiiv for his newsletter and runs a native referral program (1 referral gets a prompt PDF, 5 referrals gets a course, 100+ referrals unlocks a virtual summit ticket). Last month referrals alone added 300 to 400 subscribers.
• Never give away your own core product for free (it cheapens the brand). Give away related items, add-ons, or excess supplier stock.
• Google knowledge panels dramatically increase the odds your brand gets cited by AI and ranks in Google, and most sellers do not know they can claim one.

Why most Amazon sellers will fail in 2025

Most Amazon sellers will fail in 2025 because they are running 2017 playbooks (long keyword-stuffed titles, keyword-stuffed bullets, no brand differentiation) at a time when Amazon rewards brand, community, and off-platform traffic more than raw keyword optimization. Norm Farrar, who has torn apart hundreds of listings on his “Trash My Product” segment, says most sellers still have no idea their listings look like they were built five years ago.

The winning sellers are doing three things differently: they build a brand distinct enough that a buyer would type its name into Amazon directly, they build an owned audience (newsletter, community, SMS list) so they can drive external traffic to their listings, and they invest in content and referrals that keep their brand top-of-mind between purchases.

The gap is not talent. It is that most sellers are still optimizing the listing when the leverage moved to what happens before and after the shopper sees the listing.

How to build a brand community around an Amazon or DTC product

The way to build a brand community around a product is to give away a recurring, high-value asset (like a weekly meal plan for a knife brand or a fact-of-the-week for a niche product) that people actually want to receive, capture the email via a QR code on the packaging, and funnel those emails into a group where the topic is the niche, not the product. Norm’s case study is a knife brand that went from zero followers to a 7,000-person Facebook group by giving away a weekly meal plan.

The client’s stack, step by step:

1. Fix the packaging first. The knife’s original packaging was bad. New packaging raised perceived value and gave the brand permission to sit at a higher price point.
2. Add a QR code to the package. The code leads to a landing page with a lifetime warranty offer, a free cookbook, and a weekly meal plan subscription. All three feed the email list.
3. Seed content by gifting product to chefs and culinary schools. Chefs and students provided recipes plus UGC (photos, videos of them holding the knife). That content stocked three cookbooks and every social channel.
4. Grow the group with meal plans, not sales pitches. The Facebook group grew to 7,000 people around recipes and cooking tips. The brand is present in the group but does not spam it.
5. Run contests that generate UGC. Buyers post photos of the knives on Instagram, which pulls more people into the group.
6. Launch new products to the community. The brand now has 11 knives. Every product launch goes to the community first with almost no discounting required.

The whole engine works because the shared interest is cooking, not knives. Buyers stay engaged with each other over recipes. The brand sells more knives as a natural byproduct.

What platform should you build your community on: Facebook, WhatsApp, or Discord?

The right platform for a brand community depends on the audience: WhatsApp beats Facebook Groups for high-engagement business and B2B communities where members want direct chat, while Facebook Groups still work best for consumer niche communities (recipes, hobbies, DIY) where the content-share format is native. Norm’s own community migrated from Facebook to WhatsApp and saw meaningfully higher engagement.

The other platforms worth considering are Discord (Norm admits it is over his head, and it is where a lot of Gen Z and gaming-adjacent audiences live), Telegram (Norm’s guest Gracie Rybak swears by it, but Norm shut his down to reduce channel sprawl), Circle and School (subscription community platforms), and community-inside-newsletter platforms like Beehiiv.

Regardless of platform, one structural move that scales: split your community into topical sub-groups. Norm runs five WhatsApp sub-groups under one master community (sourcing, events, general lounge, etc.). Each has its own do’s and don’ts and its own culture, which prevents the spam-and-noise collapse that happens when everyone posts in one channel.

Why your newsletter should be the center of your community strategy

Your newsletter should be the center of your community strategy because it is the highest-lead-generating asset in most brand-community stacks. Norm’s newsletter now beats his podcast for lead generation, and he says he would have started it years earlier if he had known.

The Beehiiv-native referral program is the compounding engine. Norm keeps the first tier low friction (one referral gets a prompt PDF), then stacks rewards as the numbers grow: five referrals gets a small course (Norm partnered with Mark Degrasse for the giveaway), higher tiers get his Honu Tariff Terminator ($400 value) or Kevin King’s virtual summit ticket at 100+ referrals. Last month the referral program alone added 300 to 400 new subscribers to Norm’s list.

Beehiiv handles the referral tracking, unique referral links, and reward unlocks natively. That is a big deal because bolting on a referral system with third-party tools like SparkLoop or ReferralHero adds work that stops many operators from ever launching one.

What Norm puts in the newsletter to keep engagement high

Norm’s weekly newsletter combines one personal story with a business twist, plus a recurring contest called “Wheel of Kelsey” tied to that week’s podcast episode, plus one signature format element (a poll under key articles). Every brand needs its own version of the recurring format hook: for a food brand a recipe of the week, for a pet brand a fact of the day, for a supplement brand a stack of the week.

How to bootstrap a Facebook Group or WhatsApp community from zero

You bootstrap a brand community from zero by posting daily yourself at the start (or more), seeding conversation with polls and questions, running contests to generate engagement, and asking the group directly what content they want more or less of. Norm posted heavily in his own WhatsApp community for months, and only backed off when engagement stayed steady with less input.

Two structural moves he uses now:

• Post relevant news the group actually cares about. Any big Amazon or AI update goes into the group with a short framing. When a major Facebook hack made news, Norm posted it and the group exploded with 25 to 50 chats.
• Ask the group how much content they want from you. When engagement dropped a few percent, Norm asked directly whether the group wanted more updates or wanted him to back off. The answer was a specific dose: one or two Amazon updates per week, more if truly interesting.

Norm’s engagement math: even in a 500-person group, roughly 10% (about 50 people) drive most of the conversation. Those are the people who become your unofficial moderators, referrers, and brand ambassadors. Chase engagement, not follower count.

Which contest and giveaway incentives work best for brand communities?

The contest incentives that work best in a brand community are related products (accessories, add-ons, third-party items) rather than your own core product, because giving away your own core product for free cheapens the brand in the shopper’s mind. Norm’s rule: give away a set of AirPods, a related tool, or excess supplier stock, but never your flagship product at zero dollars.

The exception is products you deliberately do not sell in your store. On my own DTC store I give away a wedding handkerchief in exchange for a phone number for SMS.

The handkerchief is not in our catalog, so it does not devalue anything on the site. The stock is excess inventory from a supplier who just wants to move it.

How to manage a growing brand community without burning out

You manage a growing brand community without burning out by installing moderators (usually volunteers who emerge from the top 10% of engaged members), gating entry with 4 approval questions to filter spammers, splitting the community into topical sub-groups, and using a communication aggregator like Ramboxx to consolidate every channel into one interface.

Norm’s community started fully self-managed. Once about five volunteer moderators emerged from the active members, he stepped back to weekly check-ins and the community kept running. Spammers get removed in about 30 seconds because the moderators are motivated by the same brand-fit values as the community itself.

The tool tip that saved him hours is Ramboxx (roughly $3/month), which piles every messaging and social channel into one desktop app with per-channel icons. His assistant handles anything generic and only surfaces urgent messages to him. It is a small tool that gives back a lot of hours per week.

Why every serious brand needs a Google knowledge panel

Every serious brand needs a Google knowledge panel because the panel is one of Google’s strongest signals of authority, and without it your odds of ranking (and of getting cited by AI answer engines) drop significantly. AI models like ChatGPT and Perplexity cite entities Google recognizes as authoritative, and the knowledge panel is Google’s structured entity record for your brand or person.

To claim one, Google your own name or brand, click the three dots on the panel that appears, and click “Claim this knowledge panel.” Google will ask for a government ID (a passport photo is common) and manually verify you within 1 to 5 days. Different keywords can generate different panels (Norm has 12 panels across “Amazon,” “Lunch With Norm,” “Marketing Misfits,” and other keyword phrases), and merging them takes a separate Google request.

The rejection cases Norm has seen are usually cases where the applicant submitted the wrong role. Apply as the credential Google can most easily verify: podcast host if you host a podcast, public speaker if you speak at events, author if you have a published book.

Present one strong credential rather than a vague mix.

Frequently asked questions

Why do most Amazon sellers fail in 2025?

Most Amazon sellers fail in 2025 because they still run 2017 tactics (keyword-stuffed titles, weak bullets, weak brand, and zero owned audience) while the winning sellers build off-Amazon communities, newsletters, and referral loops that pull demand to their listings and let them stop competing on price.

Should I build my community on Facebook, WhatsApp, or Discord?

WhatsApp beats Facebook Groups for high-engagement business and B2B communities, while Facebook Groups still work best for consumer niche communities where content-sharing is native (recipes, hobbies, DIY). Discord and Telegram are worth testing if your audience already lives there. The right choice is wherever your specific audience already spends time.

What is the best newsletter tool for building a brand community?

Beehiiv is the best newsletter tool for building a brand community that includes a referral loop, because it has native referral tracking and reward tiers built in without third-party bolt-ons. Norm’s newsletter is on Beehiiv and its referral program alone added 300 to 400 subscribers in a single recent month.

How do I get people into my community from Amazon customers?

You get people into your community from Amazon customers by putting a dynamic QR code on your product packaging that leads to a landing page offering something high-value (lifetime warranty, free cookbook, weekly meal plan, exclusive content). Dynamic QR codes let you change the offer without reprinting packaging.

Should I give away my own product to grow my community?

No, giving away your own core product for free cheapens the brand in customers’ minds. Give away related items, accessories, add-ons, or excess supplier stock instead. The one exception is products you do not carry in your own store, which cannot devalue your active catalog.

How do I claim a Google knowledge panel for my brand?

To claim a Google knowledge panel, Google your name or brand, click the three dots on the panel that appears, click “Claim this knowledge panel,” and submit a government ID plus proof of your role (author, podcast host, public speaker, brand founder). Google manually verifies within 1 to 5 days.

What is Ramboxx and why do community operators use it?

Ramboxx is a low-cost desktop app (roughly $3/month) that consolidates every messaging and social channel (Slack, WhatsApp, Messenger, and social DMs) into one interface, so operators can manage a large community without switching between 10 apps. Norm uses it and has an assistant answer generic messages while flagging urgent ones.

Ready To Get Serious About Starting An Online Business?

If you are really considering starting your own online business, then you have to check out my free mini course on How To Create A Niche Online Store In 5 Easy Steps.

In this 6 day mini course, I reveal the steps that my wife and I took to earn 100 thousand dollars in the span of just a year. Best of all, it's absolutely free!