643: We’re Ditching WordPress After 12 Years. Here’s Why

Podcast: Download (Duration: 41:40 — 48.0MB)

For a brand-new ecommerce blog in 2026, put it on Shopify’s native blog, not WordPress. My co-host Toni and I spent the last decade recommending WordPress as the gold standard for ecommerce content, and we have both changed our minds for most new-store situations. The tracking, AI-search behavior, user-experience, and consolidated-platform math has all flipped in Shopify’s favor.

That does NOT mean migrating an existing 12-year-old WordPress blog with real authority. Redirects still hurt in AI search, and I would leave a proven WordPress blog exactly where it is. But for any brand-new content going forward, and for any store that has a small or stagnant WordPress blog, Shopify’s native blog is now the better call.

Below is the full breakdown: what changed since we first recommended WordPress, why Shopify’s tracking-and-attribution problem has become WordPress’s problem instead, when NOT to migrate an existing WordPress blog, and the state of blogging in 2026 (short version: dead as a standalone business, alive as an AI-mention engine for stores).

Get My Free Mini Course On How To Start A Successful Ecommerce Store

If you are interested in starting an ecommerce business, I put together a comprehensive package of resources that will help you launch your own online store from complete scratch. Be sure to grab it before you leave!

Click Here To Download

Key takeaways

• Standalone informational blogs with nothing to sell are dead as a business in 2026. Blogging only makes sense today if your site actually sells something.
• The purpose of an ecommerce blog in 2026 is to get mentioned in AI answers (ChatGPT, Claude, Perplexity, Google AI Overviews), not to rank blue links. Google now favors blogs attached to real transaction businesses.
• My Bumblebee Linens blog (attached to the store) is up ~40% in traffic since December. My standalone My Wife Quit Her Job blog is DOWN ~40% year-to-date. Both use the same tactics; the difference is one is attached to a store.
• Shopify’s native blog has closed most of the historical gap with WordPress. The remaining WordPress advantages (a mature plugin library, more layout control) rarely outweigh Shopify’s tracking, attribution, and AI-friendly consolidation.
• Do NOT migrate a 12-year-old WordPress blog with existing authority. Redirects hurt in AI search. Leave the legacy content where it is and write NEW content on Shopify.
• If your existing WordPress blog is small or stagnant (no traffic, weak domain), just move everything to Shopify and consolidate.
• Advertorial-style posts (long-form content that answers a real question and links to your products) still work extremely well. Whether they live on WordPress or Shopify matters less than whether they exist.

Is blogging still worth it for an ecommerce business in 2026?

Blogging is still worth it for an ecommerce business in 2026 IF the blog exists to get you mentioned in AI answers and to drive people into your store, not to build a standalone content business. The blogs attached to real transaction sites are up in traffic; the standalone informational blogs are down. My Bumblebee Linens blog is up ~40% since December while My Wife Quit Her Job (no store attached) is down ~40% over the same window.

Google is actively favoring content on sites that sell something. The signal is: “when someone searches this term, do we send them to a site that can actually solve the transaction, or a site that will just talk about it?” AI engines follow a similar logic when deciding what to cite. A blog post from a store selling handkerchiefs will get cited on “handkerchief gift ideas” more often than a blog post from a pure content site on the same topic.

The tactical implication: if you are running an ecommerce store, blog. Just do it inside the store. If you are running a pure content business with no products or services to sell, the business model is not viable anymore.

Why did we switch from WordPress to Shopify for ecommerce blogging?

We switched from recommending WordPress to recommending Shopify’s native blog because the four historical advantages of WordPress (superior editor, plugin library, better SEO, and same-domain hosting) have either closed or reversed. Meanwhile, four Shopify advantages (unified tracking, AI-search preference for consolidated sites, better ad attribution, and cleaner user experience) have grown into decisive edges.

The historical WordPress advantages, ranked by how much they still matter:

• Plugin library: still bigger than Shopify’s, but modern Shopify covers most of what a blog needs (SEO, table of contents, alt text). Advantage: WordPress, but narrower.
• SEO: WordPress used to outrank Shopify on identical content. That gap is gone. Both platforms rank fine now.
• Editor flexibility: WordPress used to blow Shopify away. Shopify has closed enough of the gap that it no longer matters for most posts.
• Same-domain hosting: the killer WordPress advantage of putting your blog at yoursite.com/blog instead of blog.yoursite.com. Shopify has fixed this in 2025-2026 with subfolder support.

The Shopify advantages that have grown decisive:

• Unified tracking: one Google Analytics account, one Meta pixel context, one attribution model. No cross-subdomain gymnastics.
• AI-search consolidation preference: AI engines appear to favor sites where everything (content and products) lives in one ecosystem.
• Ad attribution: when you send Meta or Google traffic to a blog post that lives on Shopify, the ad platform can track the full purchase funnel. On a WordPress subdomain, that funnel is broken.
• User experience: landing on a Shopify blog post feels like being in a store. Landing on a WordPress blog feels like leaving one. Add-to-cart on a Shopify blog is one click; on a WordPress subdomain, it is a jump.

Did the WordPress-WP Engine drama affect this decision?

The WordPress-WP Engine drama in late 2024 did not directly affect our recommendation, but it did leave a bad taste with a lot of developers and made “is WordPress really open source?” a legitimate question. Matt Mullenweg (CEO of Automattic, the company behind WordPress) blocked WP Engine from accessing the WordPress plugin repository over a personal beef and sued them in court. The whole thing looked like an abuse of the “open source” positioning that made WordPress popular in the first place.

The developer revolt led to alternative platforms getting traction, though none has broken through enough to name here. For most ecommerce store owners the drama is a footnote. But if you were on the fence about WordPress before, this made the decision easier.

Should you migrate an existing WordPress blog to Shopify?

You should NOT migrate an existing WordPress blog to Shopify if the blog has real authority, traffic, and years of accumulated backlinks. Redirects hurt in AI search (and in Google), and moving 100+ posts creates a redirect chain that will bleed authority for months or years. Leave the legacy content where it is and start writing NEW content on Shopify going forward.

The migration decision matrix:

• Existing WordPress blog with 5+ years of authority and real traffic: do NOT migrate. Keep the WordPress blog running for legacy content, write new content on Shopify.
• Existing WordPress blog with weak domain, no traffic, or under 1 year old: migrate to Shopify. The redirect pain is small; the consolidation win is large.
• No existing blog, starting from zero: Shopify’s native blog, no question.

Toni’s client fits the first category: 12+ year old WordPress blog, still drives revenue, hundreds of ranking posts. Migrating that risks losing everything that already works. Instead, all NEW posts go on Shopify, and the WordPress blog continues to serve its existing rankings.

Why do redirects hurt in AI search?

Redirects hurt in AI search because AI crawlers appear to deprioritize URLs that redirect elsewhere, and because the citation graph AI models build associates authority with specific URLs. When you redirect from oldsite.com/post to newsite.com/post, the new URL has to re-earn its citations from scratch, and the AI models that had ingested the old URL do not automatically update their associations.

Google’s traditional 301 redirect logic (which passes ~99% of link authority to the new URL) does not fully translate to how AI engines track content. This is still an evolving area, but the safe assumption is: every redirect costs you something in AI search visibility, and mass redirects during a migration cost you a lot.

What kind of blog content still works for ecommerce in 2026?

The blog content that still works for ecommerce in 2026 is problem-solving content (“beef stroganoff without mushrooms,” “how to get rid of ants”) and gift guides (“second-year wedding anniversary gifts,” “gifts for the groom”). Both types answer a specific question and then link the reader to products that solve it. Personal-essay-style blogging is dead; procedural problem-solving content is thriving.

Two Bumblebee Linens examples that are driving the ~40% traffic lift:

• Gift guides: “second year wedding anniversary gift” (cotton is the traditional gift). The post ranks, drives traffic, and every product mentioned is a Bumblebee Linens SKU with a direct add-to-cart link.
• Wedding season content: “gifts for the groom,” “handkerchief use for weddings.” Seasonal traffic peaks that convert well because the reader has commercial intent.

The pattern that makes these work: the reader has a specific problem, the post answers it directly, and the products that solve it are one click away. No personal narrative or brand storytelling gets in the way; just the answer and the products.

What content should ecommerce stores stop writing in 2026?

Ecommerce stores should stop writing personal-essay content, generic industry commentary, and “a day in the life” posts. None of that ranks, none of it gets cited by AI, and none of it drives store revenue. The kind of blog post that took a full Sunday morning at a coffee shop to write is not the format that wins in 2026.

The winning format is question-answer-question-answer, because AI engines chunk and cite content this way and human readers with commercial intent scan this way. If your posts require a reader to invest 5 minutes in your personal story before they get to the useful content, they will bounce.

How do advertorials fit into the ecommerce blog strategy?

Advertorials are long-form blog posts that answer a specific reader question in depth and then link naturally to the products that solve the underlying problem. They work extremely well in 2026 because they combine the problem-solving format that AI cites with the commercial intent that ranks. Whether the advertorial lives on WordPress or Shopify matters less than whether it exists at all.

The examples that have been working:

• Male hair-fullness product with an advertorial that discusses factors in hair thinning and closes with an add-to-cart. Simon at Seller Summit shared this pattern.
• “How to teach my kid to read” from a homeschool-authority brand, with 16 steps and product recommendations woven in.
• Any long-form guide from a founder with credentials (teacher, degree, publishing history) writing on their area of expertise.

The differentiator on Shopify is that the add-to-cart button can literally live inside the post. On WordPress, you need to link to the Shopify product page as a separate hop, which loses conversions. For advertorials specifically, Shopify’s native blog has a decisive UX edge.

What are the tracking and attribution problems with a WordPress blog on a subdomain?

The tracking and attribution problems with a WordPress blog on a subdomain are that Google Analytics, Meta ads, and most attribution tools treat blog.yoursite.com and yoursite.com as separate properties, breaking the full funnel view. When you run Meta ads driving traffic to a blog post that leads to a product page on the main domain, Meta cannot attribute the conversion cleanly. When you look at analytics, you have to switch between two accounts and manually reconcile the data.

The specific pain points:

• Google Analytics: two properties, two dashboards, two attribution windows. Cross-domain tracking is possible but fragile.
• Meta pixel: the pixel fires on the blog subdomain and on the store, but Meta’s optimization struggles to connect blog-post-view to product-purchase because they are technically different origins.
• Klaviyo / email attribution: abandoned-cart flows, browser-abandonment, and post-purchase flows are all optimized for a single-domain experience. Cross-subdomain breaks parts of this.
• Ad platform optimization: Meta’s algorithm needs clean signal to optimize toward purchase. Broken subdomain tracking gives it dirty signal, which hurts ROAS.

Frequently asked questions

Should a new ecommerce store use WordPress or Shopify for its blog in 2026?

Use Shopify’s native blog for any new ecommerce store in 2026, because WordPress’s historical advantages (better editor, bigger plugin library, subdomain SEO parity) have all either closed or reversed. Shopify’s unified tracking, AI-search consolidation preference, cleaner ad attribution, and better user experience now decisively outweigh what WordPress still does slightly better. The old default of “always WordPress for blogging” no longer applies.

Should I migrate my existing WordPress blog to Shopify?

Only migrate if your existing WordPress blog has weak authority, low traffic, or is under a year old. If your WordPress blog has 5+ years of authority, real ranking posts, and drives meaningful revenue, do NOT migrate, because redirects hurt in AI search and Google and mass redirects can bleed authority for months. Instead, keep the legacy WordPress blog for existing content and write all NEW content on Shopify.

Is blogging still worth doing for an ecommerce store in 2026?

Yes, if you use the blog to get mentioned in AI answers and drive people to your products rather than to build a standalone content business. Blogs attached to real transaction sites are gaining traffic in 2026 (Bumblebee Linens is up ~40% since December), while standalone informational blogs with nothing to sell are losing traffic (my personal blog is down ~40% year-to-date). Google and AI both favor content on sites that sell something.

What kind of blog posts should an ecommerce store write?

Write problem-solving posts (“beef stroganoff without mushrooms”) and gift guides (“second-year wedding anniversary gifts”). Both answer a specific question and link directly to products that solve the underlying problem. Skip personal essays, day-in-the-life posts, and general brand storytelling; the winning format is question-answer-question-answer, which is how AI engines chunk and cite content.

What is an advertorial and does it still work in 2026?

An advertorial is a long-form blog post that answers a specific reader question in depth and closes with links (or add-to-cart buttons) for the products that solve the underlying problem. Advertorials work extremely well in 2026, especially on Shopify where the add-to-cart can live inside the post. The format is winning because it combines the problem-solving content that AI cites with the commercial intent that ranks.

Why did Google’s Helpful Content Update hurt so many blogs?

Google’s Helpful Content Update decimated a lot of standalone informational blogs, including ours and most of the ecommerce-adjacent blogs in our peer network, because it started favoring content on sites with real business behind them (products, services, transactions). Standalone blogs got downranked in favor of content from stores, brands, and service businesses. This is one of the biggest reasons the “ecommerce store + blog on the same domain” model is now winning while pure content sites are losing.

Ready To Get Serious About Starting An Online Business?

If you are really considering starting your own online business, then you have to check out my free mini course on How To Create A Niche Online Store In 5 Easy Steps.

In this 6 day mini course, I reveal the steps that my wife and I took to earn 100 thousand dollars in the span of just a year. Best of all, it's absolutely free!