
Podcast: Download (Duration: 13:41 — 16.0MB)
In this Family First Friday episode of the My Wife Quit Her Job podcast, I walk through the only four ecommerce platforms I would consider for a new online store: Shopify, Shift4Shop, WooCommerce, and BigCommerce. Each one wins for a different type of seller depending on budget, tech skill, product type, and how much you care about SEO and blogging.
My short-answer recommendation: pick Shopify if you want the safest, easiest choice and have money to burn on apps. Pick BigCommerce if you want a fuller feature set out of the box with better SEO. Pick Shift4Shop if you are in the US and want a powerful cart for essentially $14.50 a month. Pick WooCommerce if you are tech savvy and want the cheapest, most flexible setup on the planet.
Below is a full breakdown of each platform’s real strengths and weaknesses so you can pick without regretting it 12 months in.
Key takeaways
- Statista lists WooCommerce as the largest global ecommerce platform by market share, followed by Squarespace, Shopify, and Wix. Two of my top four (Shift4Shop and BigCommerce) do not even crack that list.
- Shopify’s real cost is apps: the average Shopify store uses 7 apps, and my course students pay several hundred dollars per month on recurring app fees on top of the base plan.
- Shift4Shop is effectively free ($14.50/month equivalent in credit card fees) once you process at least $500 in monthly payments through Shift4Payments.
- WooCommerce is the cheapest and most SEO-friendly option and can be launched for as little as $3, but you own all server maintenance, security, and updates.
- BigCommerce is priced by revenue tier ($29.99, $79, $299 per month) and includes features (no transaction fees, better SEO, better WordPress blog integration) that Shopify charges apps to replicate.
How to pick the best ecommerce platform for your online store
The best ecommerce platform for your online store depends on four inputs: your budget, your technical skill, the products you sell, and how much you care about SEO and blogging. There is no universal winner, which is why most “top 10 ecommerce platforms” listicles that just point at Shopify are useless.
Ignore raw market share when picking. Free platforms like WooCommerce dominate global usage because 90% of the sign-ups never make a sale, so the leaderboard is skewed by hobby stores that never take off.
Instead, match the platform to your real constraints. Every option below is a legitimate seven-figure cart in the right hands; the question is which one fits how you plan to run and grow your store.
Shopify: the safest ecommerce platform for most new sellers
Shopify is the safest ecommerce platform to recommend for most new sellers because it is easy to use, has the largest third-party app ecosystem, and has the most developer talent available for hire. The old saying applies: no one ever got fired for recommending Shopify.
The core Shopify product is deliberately bare-bones, which was a genius early strategy. It forced third parties to build the missing features into the App Store, which now has apps for essentially every feature you can imagine.
The downside is cost. The average Shopify store uses 7 apps, and each app is a monthly fee. Advanced discount rules can be $20 to $50 a month, video reviews another $50, and so on, and it adds up.
There are five other real Shopify weaknesses worth knowing before you sign up.
- Bad blogging platform. Shopify’s built-in blog is weak, which matters if you plan to build content-driven organic traffic.
- Transaction fees on non-Shopify payments. If you accept PayPal (which almost every store should for one-click checkout), Shopify’s transaction fee penalty can push your total payment cost near 5%.
- Poor international support. Countries outside the US, Canada, UK, Europe, and Singapore are largely unsupported.
- Suboptimal SEO URL structure. Shopify forces “collections” and “products” into your URLs and does not let you fully customize them.
- Product variant cap. Only 3 option types and 100 total variant combinations, which is a hard limit if you sell apparel, jewelry, or anything with many SKUs.
Real-world app example from Seller Summit 2023: Walmart Marketplace built a Shopify app that automatically imports your Shopify products into Walmart. It only works with Shopify because developers ship to Shopify first for the recurring revenue.
Shift4Shop: powerful ecommerce platform for $14.50 a month
Shift4Shop is the most feature-rich ecommerce platform you can run for under $15 a month, as long as you are in the US and can process at least $500 per month through Shift4Payments. Below that threshold the cart costs $29 a month; above it, the cart is free.
The math: charging your own credit card $500 a month costs about 2.9% or $14.50 in processing fees. That gets you a cart that is more powerful out of the box than Shopify, with free built-in email marketing and support for eight-figure enterprise stores.
The biggest downside is the interface. Shift4Shop packs a huge feature set into one back end, which creates a steeper learning curve than Shopify. My teenage daughter picked it up in a weekend and launched her jewelry shop at renabee.com, so it is doable, but plan on the extra ramp time.
The other weakness is a small developer community. New integrations (like the Walmart Marketplace Shopify app I just mentioned) will land on Shift4Shop much later, if at all.
WooCommerce: the cheapest and most SEO-friendly ecommerce platform
WooCommerce is the cheapest and most SEO-friendly ecommerce platform because it is 100% free open-source software that runs on top of WordPress, which powers over 20% of the web and is still the best blogging platform on the planet. You can launch a real store for as little as $3 with a basic web host.
The catch is that you own everything. WooCommerce is just software, so you need a web host, and you are responsible for server maintenance, security patches, plugin updates, and recovery if you get hacked. Shopify and Shift4Shop handle all that for you.
The upside of ownership is real. You control the source code, you have zero platform gatekeepers, and you can sell products that hosted platforms will not touch. During the pandemic Shopify shut down a friend’s store for selling hand sanitizer at what Shopify decided was too high a price. Shopify also bans drugs and various chemicals from the platform, and their enforcement can be arbitrary.
WooCommerce also has excellent third-party developer support because it is the most-used cart in the world, so finding help is easy. If my 9- and 11-year-old kids can run their store at kidincharge.com on WooCommerce, most adults with an hour of patience can too.
BigCommerce: the best out-of-the-box ecommerce platform for growing stores
BigCommerce is the best out-of-the-box ecommerce platform for stores that want Shopify-level ease of use with more built-in features and better SEO. It combines the polish of Shopify with much of the depth of Shift4Shop, and it charges no transaction fees no matter which payment processor you use.
BigCommerce has one feature Shopify cannot match: a first-class WordPress integration that lets you run your BigCommerce store and a WordPress blog on the same domain. For content-driven brands that matters a lot, because your blog authority feeds your product pages.
Other real strengths: no product variant limits, better international support, superior analytics and reporting, and a much smaller app dependency than Shopify. The main weakness is a smaller developer ecosystem than Shopify, though still bigger than Shift4Shop.
Pricing is tiered by revenue, which is either a feature or a bug depending on your model.
| Monthly plan | Revenue ceiling | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| $29.99 | Up to $50K/year | New stores |
| $79 | Up to $180K/year | Growing stores |
| $299 | Up to $400K/year | Established stores |
The revenue-tier pricing hurts if you run a drop-shipping store with 5% net margins, because the flat fee is a bigger percentage of a small profit pool. For higher-margin private-label or branded products, it scales sensibly.
Ecommerce platforms compared side by side
Here is the side-by-side comparison of all four platforms on the dimensions that actually matter.
| Platform | Starting cost | Ease of use | SEO/blogging | Transaction fees | Product variants | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shopify | $29/mo + apps | Easiest | Weak blog, forced URL structure | Yes on non-Shopify Payments | 3 options, 100 combos | Beginners with budget for apps |
| Shift4Shop | ~$14.50/mo effective (US) | Steeper learning curve | Solid, includes free email marketing | No | Unlimited | US sellers who want maximum features cheaply |
| WooCommerce | From $3/mo (web host) | Requires tech skill | Best in class (WordPress) | No | Unlimited | Content-first brands and tinkerers |
| BigCommerce | $29.99/mo | Easy | Great, with WordPress integration | No | Unlimited | Growing stores wanting fewer apps |
Which ecommerce platform should you actually pick?
Pick the platform that matches your specific constraint, and do not overthink it. The four scenarios below cover almost every new seller I meet.
Choose Shopify if you are new, not tech savvy, have budget for monthly app fees, and want the biggest developer ecosystem to grow into. You will pay more over time but the ramp is the fastest.
Choose BigCommerce if you want most of Shopify’s ease with fewer app dependencies, need PayPal without a transaction penalty, sell products with many variants, or want a real WordPress blog on the same domain.
Choose Shift4Shop if BigCommerce is out of budget, you live in the United States, and you can process $500 a month through Shift4Payments to unlock the free plan. It has the most functionality per dollar of any platform on this list.
Choose WooCommerce if you are tech savvy, want the cheapest possible start, care most about SEO and content, or sell products that hosted platforms restrict. Plan on owning security and maintenance in exchange for full control.
Frequently asked questions
What is the best ecommerce platform for beginners in 2023?
Shopify is the best ecommerce platform for beginners in 2023 because it has the shallowest learning curve, the largest app ecosystem, and the most developer talent available for hire. The tradeoff is monthly app fees that push the true cost well above the base $29 plan for most stores.
Is WooCommerce really free?
WooCommerce the software is 100% free, but you have to pay for a web host to run it (from about $3 to $30 per month) and you are responsible for security, backups, and plugin updates. Add-on plugins for advanced features often cost extra, though the free defaults cover most stores.
Does Shopify charge extra fees for using PayPal?
Yes. If you accept PayPal on Shopify without using Shopify Payments as your primary processor, Shopify adds a transaction fee on every PayPal order. Combined with PayPal’s own fee, the total payment cost can approach 5%, which is high enough that many Shopify stores skip PayPal despite the one-click checkout benefit.
What is the cheapest ecommerce platform that can support a real store?
WooCommerce is the cheapest legitimate ecommerce platform because the cart software is free and you only pay for hosting, which can be as little as $3 per month. Shift4Shop is the cheapest hosted (fully managed) option at an effective $14.50 per month for US sellers who process $500 monthly through Shift4Payments.
Which ecommerce platform has the best SEO?
WooCommerce has the best SEO because it runs on WordPress, which is the strongest blogging and content platform on the web. BigCommerce is second because it also integrates cleanly with WordPress for content, and Shopify is weakest because it forces non-editable URL structures like /collections/ and /products/.
Can I sell products with many variants on Shopify?
Not comfortably. Shopify limits products to 3 option types and 100 total variant combinations, which is a hard cap for apparel, jewelry, or anything with size, color, and style options. BigCommerce, Shift4Shop, and WooCommerce all support unlimited variants, so pick one of those for variant-heavy catalogs.
Which ecommerce platform is best for drop shipping?
Shopify has the deepest drop-shipping app ecosystem, but BigCommerce’s revenue-tiered pricing can eat a bigger percentage of thin drop-shipping margins on small stores. Shift4Shop and WooCommerce both work well if you want lower fixed costs, provided you are comfortable with less specialized drop-shipping tooling.
I Need Your Help
If you enjoyed listening to this podcast, then please support me with a review on Apple Podcasts. It's easy and takes 1 minute! Just click here to head to Apple Podcasts and leave an honest rating and review of the podcast. Every review helps!
Ready To Get Serious About Starting An Online Business?
If you are really considering starting your own online business, then you have to check out my free mini course on How To Create A Niche Online Store In 5 Easy Steps.
In this 6 day mini course, I reveal the steps that my wife and I took to earn 100 thousand dollars in the span of just a year. Best of all, it's absolutely free!































