Printful vs Printify. Which print on demand company is best for you? This post will break down and compare the 2 most popular POD companies from the perspective of a real shop owner that has used both services.
In order to start an online store, you first need to source products to sell. But the problem with product sourcing is that it’s impossible to predict demand.
Should you spend your money upfront buying 1000 t-shirts in a variety of sizes when you have no idea which size or design will be popular?
Or do you play it safe, place a small order and run the potential of running out of stock?
Especially when you are first starting out, you should avoid spending all of your money on inventory until you know that your products will sell.
Thanks to print on demand companies(POD) like Printify and Printful, you don’t have to spend a dime upfront for inventory.
When an order comes in, you simply send your order information to your POD company, and they fulfill and ship your product to the end customer.
In this post, I’ve written up a full comparison of the 2 most popular print on demand companies, Printful vs Printify. Unlike other reviews you see on the Internet, I’ve actually used and evaluated both services to sell t-shirts online.
Get My Free Mini Course On How To Start A Successful Ecommerce Store
If you are interested in starting an ecommerce business, I put together a comprehensive package of resources that will help you launch your own online store from complete scratch. Be sure to grab it before you leave!
What Is Print On Demand?
Print on demand is a form of dropshipping where you work with a supplier to place your own brand and design on a generic white label product like a t-shirt or a mug.
You don’t have to spend any money upfront on inventory. When an order comes in, the print on demand company creates your product with your design on the fly and ships it to your customer.
You don’t pay for the product until after it’s already been sold which means that you can start selling your own branded products with little or no upfront cost.
Every aspect of product fulfillment is taken care of by the print on demand company so you can focus on marketing and sales.
As long as you are using a supported shopping cart, the entire process is 100% automated. When an order comes in on your website, it is automatically sent and fulfilled by your POD company and you don’t have to do a thing.
Print on demand companies are great for…
- Testing your products without the burden of carrying inventory.
- Monetizing your audience with your own branded merchandise.
- Designers who want to proliferate their art.
Print On Demand Vs Importing From China
The only downside to using a print on demand company is the cost. Because you are not buying in bulk, the profit margins will be far lower than if you buy your products direct from a factory in China.
For example, importing 5000 printed t-shirts from China would probably cost you anywhere from 50 cents to 2 dollars per shirt depending on quality.
However, the cost of an equivalent quality shirt from a print on demand company would cost you anywhere from 7 to 15 dollars per piece.
As a result, you have to charge a lot more money for your products when you use a print on demand company in order to make a decent profit.
If you know that one of your designs is going to sell in volume, then it’s always more economical to have them produced in bulk overseas.
However, if you are just starting out and you are testing the waters, then print on demand is your best bet.
How Printful Works?
Printful does all of their own manufacturing and production and they have fulfillment centers all across the United States, Mexico and Europe.
As a result, they can ensure consistent quality from all of their facilities since they are in control of the entire supply chain.
Getting started with Printful is extremely easy and they’ve done a great job with the onboarding process.
By connecting your shopping cart directly to Printful, all incoming orders will automatically be sent and processed when a purchase is made.
After you’ve completed the integration, you can login to your Printful account and use their mockup generator to create your products.
Basically, a mockup generator is a graphical design tool that allows you to create your own custom products on their website.
For example, if you want to design a custom mug for sale, Printful provides a nice drag and drop interface to customize your mug along with pictures of the final product.
Once you are done creating your products, they are automatically sent to your shopping cart where a product listing is automatically created.
You aren’t limited to selling t-shirts and mugs either. In fact, there are over 200 products to choose from which include…
- Clothing – You can customize any piece of clothing you can think of including, t-shirts, hoodies, sweatshirts, tank tops, polos, v necks, you name it!
- Accessories – You can customize a variety of accessories including cell phone cases, jewelry, stickers, socks, masks.
- Bags – You can create your own custom tote bags, laptop cases, backpacks, fanny packs.
- Home & Living – You can customize mugs, blankets, pillows, aprons, towels.
Every product on Printful has a base price. Whenever an order comes in, Printful automatically charges your credit card for the price of the product ordered and you get to keep the difference.
Overall, the beauty of running a print on demand online store is that you can focus your time and energy on marketing and sales instead of shipping and fulfillment.
How Printify Works?
Printify works almost exactly the same way as Printful does except that their business model is completely different.
Like Printful, Printify has their own mockup generator to create your designs which are automatically imported into your shopping cart.
They also have an enormous catalog of products to choose from that is on par or larger than Printful.
But the main difference is that Printify does not manufacture or fulfill their own products. Instead, they work with independent print designers and providers with different capabilities.
On the Printify website, they have sorted and collated a large library of print on demand companies based on location, pricing and availability.
You can think of Printify like a fully integrated version of Alibaba for print on demand companies.
From this library, you have the option of hand picking your POD supplier, requesting samples and working with the print on demand provider that best suits your needs.
Once you’ve selected a provider, Printify takes care of connecting your store and managing the entire fulfillment process.
Printful Vs Printify – The Evaluation Criteria
Printful’s vertically integrated business model versus Printify’s directory based model creates some interesting pros and cons for each company.
In this post, both Printful and Printify have been evaluated based on the following parameters.
- Pricing – Which print on demand company is cheaper.
- Print Quality – Which print on demand company provides better and more consistent print quality.
- Branding Potential – Which print on demand company offers more branding options.
- Shipping And Fulfillment – Which print on demand company can ship and fulfill products faster.
- Shopping Cart Integration – Which print on demand company integrates with more ecommerce platforms.
- User Interface – Which print on demand company has a better user interface.
Printful Vs Printify – Pricing
Both Printful and Printify offer different cost structures which makes them slightly more complicated to compare in terms of price.
Printful does not charge a monthly fee and you pay on a per item basis. Every single product in Printful’s catalog has a fixed base cost.
In the example above, Printful charges a flat $8.01 for a basic t-shirt. So if you sell your shirts for $18.01, then you get to keep $10 in profit.
$8 per shirt may sound like a lot of money, but you can earn quantity discounts as your sales grow.
For example, you can earn discounts up to 10%+ if your prior month’s sales exceed a certain threshold.
Meanwhile, here are the shipping costs that Printful charges for customers residing in the United States.
Printify on the other hand, offers several monthly plans.
Overall, Printify’s free plan is good enough for most people until you reach a threshold of sales where paying for the premium plan makes sense.
The premium plan costs $29.99/month but you get a 20% discount on all products. As a result, if you sell more than $37.50 worth of product in any given month, then it’s worth paying for the plan.
Meanwhile, the price for individual products is all over the map and largely depends on the print provider you go with.
For example, a Gildan 2000 t-shirt costs $12.95 on Printful. But on Printify, your costs (along with shipping) vary dramatically depending on the provider.
As you can see above, Stakes Manufacturing charges $9.70 whereas The Dream Junction costs only $8.12.
In general, Printful’s prices will be higher than Printify. However, there is a big caveat. If you end up using multiple different providers on your shop through Printify, the shipping costs can add up quickly.
Because Printful is vertically integrated, the costs of selling multiple products in a single order will tend to be lower because shipping costs can be combined.
Meanwhile, if you use a separate provider for mugs versus shirts with Printify, you’ll incur separate shipping charges for each item.
The Verdict – Printify will be cheaper than Printful in most cases.
Printful Vs Printify – Print Quality
Judging print quality can be subjective. However, I can say that Printful offers outstanding print quality for all of the products that I’ve sourced.
Because Printful is vertically integrated, they can guarantee a consistent quality across all of their manufacturing facilities.
Printify, however, can not.
Because Printify is a collection of disparate companies, every print provider is going to offer different grades of quality, customer service and fulfillment.
As a result, if you are looking for consistent quality, Printful is a much better provider than Printify hands down. Printify does not have any control over the fulfillment process other than its role as a matchmaking service.
While it is possible to find great providers on Printify, you’ll have to do your own legwork.
The Verdict – Printful is better than Printify for consistent quality.
Printful Vs Printify – Establishing Your Brand
In an ideal world, your end customer should not be aware that you are using a print on demand company to fulfill your orders.
As a result, your shipping label, your packaging and your product should all be branded with your logo and design.
For example, both Printful and Printify will print your brand and logo on your shipping labels as shown below.
However, where Printful shines versus Printify is that they also allow you to personalize the label with your brand on the product itself.
To add a custom label, Printful charges $2.49 per label which is pricey but could be worth it to make your brand more visible.
You can also add custom package inserts for an additional $0.75 per order. For example, you can include…
- Flyers and coupons
- Business cards
- Branded stickers
- Hand-written thank you cards
While Printful offers all of these customization options, Printify does not because they don’t control their own fulfillment.
While in theory you can negotiate these add ons with the individual providers you find via Printify, these features are not nicely integrated into their service.
The Verdict – Printful wins hands down
Printful Vs Printify – Shipping And Fulfillment
Because Printify is a distributed company that does not handle their own fulfillment, the actual shipping and fulfillment times can vary dramatically depending on the provider.
In fact, the quality of provider that you find on Printify can be hit or miss.
Once again, this is where Printful shines because they can offer consistent shipping and fulfillment all under one roof.
An order on Printful takes between 2-7 business days to make for apparel products and 2-5 business days for non-apparel products.
Shipping times for Printful are also very consistent and they work with global carrier companies to fulfill their orders on time.
The only advantage that Printify has versus Printful in the shipping and fulfillment department is if you work with a provider that is local to your customer.
If you choose a Printify print provider in a location where Printful does not have a fulfillment center, you can probably get faster fulfillment times.
The Verdict – Printful offers better more consistent fulfillment.
Printful Vs Printify – Shopping Cart Integration
When it comes to shopping cart integrations, Printful has long held the lead over Printify. But in the past several years, Printify has added support for a bunch of new platforms.
As of this writing, Printify supports the following shopping carts.
Meanwhile, Printful supports many more platforms which include…
- Big Cartel
- Launch Cart
Overall, the sheer number of integrations doesn’t matter as long as your shopping cart is on the list above. But keep in mind that Printful supports many more platforms than Printify.
If you don’t see your ecommerce platform on Printify’s list, then Printful will be the obvious choice.
The Verdict – Printful supports many more integrations than Printify
Printful Vs Printify – User Interface
When it comes to finding products to sell and getting setup, I like Printful’s user interface better than Printify’s because I don’t have to worry about evaluating different suppliers.
With Printful, I simply choose a product, customize it and I’m ready to go.
But with Printify, I have to wade through a list of suppliers, get samples and try each potential supplier one by one.
While Printify does its best to screen their print providers, the print quality and shipping times can vary significantly across vendors.
In terms of product design, both Printify’s and Printful’s mockup generators get the job done and are easy to use. But overall, I find Printful’s vertically integrated platform much more appealing.
The Verdict – Both Printful and Printify offer an easy to use mockup generator but there are less steps with Printful.
Printful Vs Printify – Overall
While Printful has Printify beat in almost every category in this comparison, your choice of print on demand company will ultimately come down to price versus quality.
In most cases, Printful will be more expensive than Printify. But because they charge a premium, you get what you pay for. Printful offers consistent print quality across all of its product lines and consistent shipping and fulfillment times as well.
If you hunt through Printify’s catalog, you can always find a supplier of equivalent quality that is cheaper than Printful but it may require a few iterations.
Overall, if you sell many different types of print on demand products that require different suppliers, it’s in your best interests to go with an integrated platform like Printful.
Because Printful handles all of their own fulfilment, you can take advantage of order combining to bring your shipping costs down.
With Printify however, if you end up choosing different suppliers for shirts vs mugs vs tote bags, you could end up incurring multiple shipping fees should a customer order more than one type of product.
Furthermore, Printful offers many more branding options than Printify as well. In the end, it comes down to cost. Is Printful’s consistent quality worth the extra money?
You have to decide that for yourself.
Have you read these?
- How To Stop Overthinking, Overanalyzing And Caring What Other People Think
- How To Find The Optimal Price To Charge For Your Products
- How To Start A TShirt Business For Under 3 Dollars (And Make Sales Immediately)
- How To Become A Millionaire – 6 Ways I’ve Made Serious Money